wink

Chapter 9: The Brother Nobody Knew Existed

Kate lowered the phone.

Andrew stood at the bottom of the staircase, his briefcase open and a document in his hand.

For several seconds, neither of them spoke.

Then Kate slowly raised the phone again.

“Dad, are you still there?””

Robert's voice crackled through the speaker.

“Kate? Did you hear me?””

She stared at Andrew.

“You said Andrew Bennett was the second baby?””

“Yes.””

“Are you certain?””

Robert exhaled.

“I've known for years.””

Kate looked at the attorney.

Andrew's expression had become unreadable.

“Dad, why didn't you tell me?””

“Because I was trying to protect you.””

Kate almost laughed.

“You've used that sentence so many times that it doesn't mean anything anymore.””

“Kate, please. You need to understand what happened.””

“Then tell me.””

Robert's voice trembled.

“Thomas and Margaret had twins. Susan was unable to have children, and Thomas wanted a son he could raise as his heir. He arranged for one of the babies to be placed with her.””

Kate looked at Andrew.

“Which one?””

“Daniel.””

She swallowed.

“And the other?””

“Margaret kept him.””

Kate frowned.

“But she said the baby died.””

“That's what she told everyone.””

“Why?””

“Because she was frightened. Thomas had threatened to take both children.””

Kate stared at the wall.

“Then how did Andrew end up with another family?””

Robert paused.

“Margaret gave him away.””

The words landed heavily.

“Why would she do that?””

“Because she believed he would be safer.””

Kate closed her eyes.

She thought of the woman in the old hospital photograph.

Her mother.

Holding a newborn.

Standing beside two cribs.

How could she have given away one of her children?

And why had she never told Emily?

Robert continued.

“She arranged an adoption through a family she trusted. They lived in another state. They raised him as their own.””

Kate looked at Andrew.

“Did you know?””

Andrew slowly set the document on the table.

“I found out six weeks ago.””

Kate felt her stomach tighten.

“Six weeks?””

He nodded.

“I received a letter from Margaret's attorney. It contained a copy of the hospital record and a request that I investigate my birth.””

“Why didn't you tell me?””

“Because I didn't know whether the documents were authentic.””

Kate stared.

“You knew you might be my brother, and you still came into my house pretending to be our attorney?””

Andrew looked genuinely uncomfortable.

“I was trying to establish the truth before making an accusation.””

Kate shook her head.

“Another person deciding what I'm allowed to know.””

Andrew lowered his eyes.

“I understand.””

“No, I don't think you do.””

She walked toward him.

“You've been sitting at my dining table, reading my mother's letters, looking at my family photographs. Did you ever once think to tell me that you might be part of this family?””

Andrew swallowed.

“Yes.””

“And?””

“I was afraid.””

“Of what?””

“Being wrong. And of discovering that the people who raised me had lied.””

Kate stared at him.

For the first time, she saw something familiar in his expression.

The same fear.

The same confusion.

The same desperate need to know where he belonged.

She stepped back.

“Who raised you?””

“A couple named Richard and Helen Bennett. They adopted me when I was three months old.””

“Do they know?””

Andrew nodded.

“My mother knew I was adopted. My father didn't know the details until recently.””

Kate looked at him.

“Are they still alive?””

“My mother died five years ago. My father is in assisted living.””

“Does he know about this?””

“Yes.””

Andrew reached into his briefcase.

“He gave me this.””

It was a small photograph.

The picture showed a young woman holding a baby.

Kate recognized Margaret immediately.

But the baby wore a bracelet.

The name on it was not Andrew.

It read:

*THOMAS CARTER JR.*

Kate's eyes filled.

“Why would they name you after your father?””

Andrew looked at the photograph.

“I don't know.””

Daniel appeared at the top of the basement stairs.

“What is going on?””

Kate turned.

“Apparently, Andrew is your twin brother.””

Daniel stopped.

“What?””

Andrew looked up.

“That's what the records suggest.””

Daniel descended the stairs slowly.

He stared at Andrew.

Then at the photograph.

For a long moment, the two men stood facing each other.

They had similar eyes.

The same shape of nose.

The same slight crease between their eyebrows.

Daniel looked older, but the resemblance was unmistakable.

He finally spoke.

“Do you believe this?””

Andrew nodded.

“I've had a preliminary DNA test.””

Kate looked at him.

“You have?””

“Yes.””

“Against whom?””

Andrew looked at Daniel.

“I used a sample from the documents Daniel provided earlier.””

Daniel frowned.

“You tested my DNA?””

“I had your written authorization when we began the trust investigation. I didn't know the result would establish a family relationship.””

Daniel looked stunned.

“What did it show?””

Andrew placed a laboratory report on the table.

“The probability of an identical twin relationship is extremely high.””

Daniel sat down.

“I'm an identical twin?””

Andrew nodded.

“Yes.””

Daniel covered his face.

Kate watched them.

Two men.

Two lives.

Two versions of the same beginning.

One raised by Susan Carter.

The other raised by Richard and Helen Bennett.

Both separated from the mother who had given birth to them.

And neither had known the other existed.

Daniel finally looked up.

“Why did she give you away?””

Andrew answered quietly.

“I don't know.””

Kate looked toward the photograph.

“Maybe we should find out.””

The next morning, they drove to the hospital archives.

Andrew had arranged access through the records administrator.

The building was old, with narrow corridors and faded photographs of doctors lining the walls.

A woman named Patricia met them near the reception desk.

She was in her sixties, with short white hair and a blue cardigan.

“Mr. Bennett?””

Andrew nodded.

“Thank you for seeing us.””

Patricia looked at Kate and Daniel.

“Are these the family members?””

“Yes.””

She led them into a small office.

A large cardboard archive box sat on the table.

“Most of these records were scheduled for destruction decades ago,” she explained.

“But someone requested that this particular file be preserved.””

Kate leaned forward.

“Who?””

Patricia opened the folder.

“The request was made by Dr. Samuel Hayes.””

Andrew frowned.

“Who was he?””

“He was the senior obstetrician on duty the night the twins were born.””

Patricia turned several pages.

“According to the notes, he suspected that a newborn had been transferred under an incorrect identity.””

Daniel stared.

“Why?””

“Because the mother had requested it.””

Kate looked up.

“Margaret?””

Patricia nodded.

“She insisted that one baby be placed with another family. But she also requested that the hospital preserve his original identity.””

Andrew leaned forward.

“Why would she do that?””

Patricia turned to the next page.

There was a handwritten statement.

It read:

The second infant must not be registered under the Carter family name. The father has threatened to take both children. I am acting in the best interests of the boys.

Kate felt her throat tighten.

“Did Thomas know?””

Patricia shook her head.

“Apparently not. The official records were changed after the transfer.””

Daniel looked at Andrew.

“Then why did Thomas believe I was his only son?””

Patricia opened another envelope.

“Because the original file contains a letter from Dr. Hayes.””

She unfolded it.

The letter was dated several months after the birth.

Mr. Carter,

I regret to inform you that the second infant was transferred to a private adoption placement at the request of the mother. I understand that you were not informed of this decision.

However, the mother has since contacted me with concerns regarding the safety of the remaining child.

Patricia stopped.

Kate looked at her.

“What concerns?””

Patricia turned the page.

She believes you may attempt to use the children to secure control of the family trust.

Daniel's face changed.

Andrew leaned back.

“The trust?””

Patricia nodded.

“There are several references to it.””

Kate felt cold.

Her mother hadn't just been trying to keep the children safe.

She had been trying to keep them away from a man who wanted something.

Thomas Carter had been involved in the family business.

And he had apparently known about the trust.

Patricia placed another document on the table.

It was a copy of a private agreement.

The title read:

*PATERNITY AND INHERITANCE ARRANGEMENT.*

Kate read the first paragraph.

It stated that Thomas would receive control of certain family assets if he could establish himself as the legal father of both boys.

She looked up.

“Why would he need to establish that?””

Andrew studied the document.

“Because Margaret's father had placed restrictions on the inheritance. The children were supposed to inherit the assets directly.””

Daniel frowned.

“So Thomas wanted control of the money.””

Patricia nodded.

“That's what the records suggest.””

Kate looked at the document again.

The dates matched the period when Thomas had been fighting with Margaret.

The period when one baby had disappeared.

The period when Margaret had started hiding documents.

Then she noticed something.

At the bottom of the agreement was a witness signature.

Robert Wilson.

Kate's breath caught.

“Dad?””

Andrew looked at the signature.

He went still.

“That's Robert's name.””

Kate stared at the paper.

Her father had witnessed an agreement that could have allowed Thomas to control the inheritance.

The same father who had raised her.

The same man who had claimed to be protecting her mother.

The same man who had taken money from the trust.

She felt sick.

“Why would he sign this?””

Daniel shook his head.

“I don't know.””

Patricia closed the folder.

“There is one more document.””

She removed a small envelope.

Inside was a photograph of Margaret, Thomas, Robert, and another woman.

The woman stood beside Thomas.

Her hand rested on his arm.

Kate recognized her from an old photograph in Daniel's album.

Susan Carter.

But it was the date on the back that caught her attention.

The picture had been taken three years before the twins were born.

And beneath the date, Margaret had written:

The day I discovered Susan wasn't Thomas's wife.

Kate looked up.

“What does that mean?””

Andrew studied the photograph.

“Perhaps Susan and Thomas weren't legally married when the children were born.””

Daniel frowned.

“But my birth certificate says they were.””

Patricia shook her head.

“According to our original records, there was no marriage certificate in the hospital file.””

Kate stared at the photograph.

Then she noticed another detail.

Margaret was holding a small document.

A marriage certificate.

The names were visible.

Thomas Carter.

Margaret Wilson.

Kate's mother had been married to Thomas before either twin was born.

Which meant Daniel and Andrew had been born during that marriage.

And Thomas had been living with another woman while Margaret believed they were building a family.

Kate looked at Andrew.

“Did your adoptive father know any of this?””

Andrew nodded slowly.

“He told me something before he died.””

“What?””

Andrew reached into his jacket and took out a folded letter.

“My adoptive father said the woman who brought me to their house wasn't a social worker.””

Kate felt her pulse quicken.

“Who was she?””

Andrew unfolded the letter.

It contained one sentence.

The woman who handed you to us was Susan Carter.

Daniel stood abruptly.

“That's impossible.””

Andrew looked at him.

“My father said Susan brought me to the house herself.””

Kate stared at the two men.

Susan had raised Daniel.

But she'd also personally delivered Andrew to another family.

Why?

And what had she been trying to hide?

Before anyone could answer, Patricia returned to the office carrying a second archive box.

“I found something else,” she said.

She placed it on the table.

“Dr. Hayes kept a private journal. It wasn't part of the official hospital records.””

Andrew opened it.

The first pages contained ordinary medical notes.

Then they reached an entry dated three days after the twins were born.

Andrew read aloud.

Mrs. Carter returned to the hospital today. She requested access to the second infant's records. When I refused, she became distressed and threatened to expose what happened during the delivery.

He turned the page.

His voice dropped.

She claims the second baby is not Margaret's child.

Kate looked up.

“What?””

Andrew continued.

She insists that the babies were switched at birth.

Daniel's face went white.

The room fell silent.

Kate looked from Andrew to Daniel.

If the babies had been switched, then the family history they'd spent their entire lives trying to understand might be completely wrong.

And the most frightening part was that the next page had been torn out.

May you like

Only a handwritten sentence remained at the bottom.

If the truth is ever discovered, the man who raised the children will know why.

Related Stories

Other posts