wink
The Door Beneath the Garden / Chapter 2 / 11

Chapter 2: The Voice in the Darkness

The first thing Gavin did was grab the door handle again.

The second thing he did was call for help.

“Someone get a crowbar!””

His voice carried across the lawn.

The garden party fell silent.

Guests began turning toward us, their conversations dying one by one.

I stepped between Gavin and the door.

“Stop this.””

He stared at me.

“Move.””

“Gavin, listen to me.””

“No. You listen to me. My sister just called my name from behind a locked door.””

A woman near the fountain gasped.

Someone whispered, “His sister?””

I looked toward the house.

My mother-in-law, Margaret, was standing beneath the white canopy.

She held a glass of lemonade in one hand and a small plate in the other.

Her silver hair was arranged in its usual immaculate bun. She wore a pale blue dress and the pearl necklace Gavin had bought her for her sixtieth birthday.

She had been watching us.

And she wasn't surprised.

Not even slightly.

That frightened me more than anything else.

“Margaret!”” Gavin shouted.

She didn't move.

“Come here!””

She placed her plate on a nearby table.

Then she walked toward us.

Slowly.

As if she were approaching a spilled drink rather than a door containing her missing daughter.

“What's all this noise?”” she asked.

Gavin pointed toward the basement.

“Tell me why Molly is down there.””

Margaret looked at the damaged door.

Then she looked at me.

Her expression barely changed.

“Gavin, darling, you're upsetting the guests.””

“Where is my sister?””

She sighed.

“Don't be ridiculous.””

“I heard her.””

“You're mistaken.””

“I know her voice!””

Margaret reached for his shoulder.

He stepped away.

“Don't touch me.””

Her lips tightened.

“Your wife has been filling your head with nonsense.””

I stared at her.

“Me?””

“Yes, Elena. You've always been dramatic.””

Gavin turned toward the entrance.

“Get me something to break this lock.””

A man from his construction company hurried forward.

“Mr. Whitmore, I have a tool kit in the van.””

“Bring it.””

The man ran.

Margaret's composure cracked.

“Gavin, don't.””

He looked at her.

“Why?””

“Because there is nothing down there.””

I almost laughed.

The words were identical to mine.

Nothing down there.

Nothing to see.

Nothing to remember.

Nothing to ask about.

Gavin took a step toward her.

“Then why are you frightened?””

Margaret's jaw tightened.

“I'm not frightened.””

“Then open it.””

She looked toward the garden.

“People are watching.””

“Good. Let them.””

A few guests quietly moved closer.

One of them, an elderly woman named Patricia, raised her phone.

I recognized her.

She had attended every summer gathering at the estate for the past six years.

“Perhaps we should call the police,” Patricia said.

Margaret turned sharply.

“That won't be necessary.””

“Why not?”” Gavin demanded.

“Because this is a private family matter.””

A voice came from behind the door.

“Please.””

Everyone stopped.

It was faint, but unmistakable.

“Please don't leave me.””

Gavin's face crumpled.

He rushed forward.

“Molly! I'm here!””

Something scraped against the other side.

Then came three weak knocks.

Knock.

Knock.

Knock.

Gavin pressed his palm against the broken wood.

“Molly, can you hear me?””

“Yes.””

The answer was barely more than a breath.

“Are you hurt?””

A pause.

Then:

“Gavin, please keep the door open.””

He looked at the narrow gap.

The broken frame had created an opening just wide enough for him to peer inside.

He bent down.

Darkness swallowed the space beyond.

The air that escaped smelled of damp stone, rust, and something unpleasantly medicinal.

He switched on his phone flashlight.

A narrow staircase descended into the earth.

At the bottom stood a second door.

It was painted white.

And someone had scratched words into it.

Gavin leaned closer.

“What is that?””

I knew what he was looking at.

I had seen those words before.

Every night for eleven years.

MOLLY WHITMORE.

Underneath, in smaller letters:

PLEASE DON'T FORGET ME.

Gavin pushed his face closer to the opening.

“Molly?””

“Gavin?””

“Yes. It's me.””

A soft sob came from below.

“I thought you weren't coming.””

He shut his eyes.

“I'm here now.””

“Is Elena there?””

My stomach tightened.

Gavin turned.

I shook my head.

Don't answer.

Don't say anything.

Don't let her hear you.

But Gavin was already looking at me.

“Yes,” he said into the darkness.

“She's here.””

Silence.

Then Molly spoke.

“Don't let her have the key.””

Every face turned toward me.

I felt my fingers curl around the small brass object hidden inside my clutch.

Gavin straightened.

“What key?””

Molly began crying.

“The little brass one. She always carries it.””

Margaret moved closer.

“That's enough.””

Gavin looked at his mother.

“What key?””

She shook her head.

“She's confused.””

Molly's voice rose from the darkness.

“I'm not confused!””

A violent bang echoed from below.

Then another.

“Gavin, please! She said she was going to come back tonight!””

Gavin stepped away from the door.

“What does that mean?””

Nobody answered.

The construction manager returned carrying a crowbar.

“Got it, sir.””

Gavin took it.

Margaret reached for his wrist.

“Don't you dare.””

He looked down at her hand.

Then he slowly removed it.

“Get away from me.””

He inserted the crowbar beneath the broken doorframe.

The first pull loosened another section of wood.

The second snapped one of the hinges.

The third tore the remaining frame apart.

The heavy door swung inward.

A wave of cold air rushed over the garden.

Guests stepped back.

Gavin aimed his phone light down the staircase.

“Molly!””

“I'm here!””

“I'm coming down.””

“No!””

The scream was so sudden that even the birds in the nearby trees scattered.

Gavin froze.

Molly's voice trembled.

“Not until you see what she did.””

He stared into the darkness.

“What are you talking about?””

“Look at the wall.””

Gavin lowered his flashlight.

The beam moved across the stone steps, revealing old water stains, broken tiles, and dozens of marks scratched into the plaster.

At first, they looked like random lines.

Then Gavin counted them.

Days.

Hundreds of them.

Some had been crossed out.

Others had been grouped into rows of ten.

There were years' worth of marks.

His breathing became uneven.

He moved the flashlight farther down.

A small metal table stood against the wall.

On it sat an empty water bottle, a cracked ceramic bowl, and a photograph.

Gavin crouched to see it.

He picked it up.

His hands began shaking.

The photograph showed a young woman sitting on the garden swing.

She was laughing.

Her dark hair fell over one shoulder.

She wore a yellow summer dress.

Gavin stared at it for several seconds.

Then he whispered:

“That's Molly.””

Margaret covered her mouth.

I stepped backward.

Gavin looked at the back of the photograph.

There was handwriting.

His handwriting.

For my little sister. Summer 2014.

He turned toward me.

“What the hell is this?””

I couldn't speak.

He looked down the stairs again.

“Molly, how long have you been here?””

The answer came after a long silence.

“Since the night you left.””

Gavin's face went white.

“The night I left for London?””

“Yes.””

“But that was eleven years ago.””

“I know.””

He gripped the railing.

“That's impossible.””

Molly gave a small, broken laugh.

“That's what Mom said too.””

Margaret suddenly shouted.

“Enough!””

The entire garden seemed to jump.

She stepped toward the entrance.

“You're all listening to a disturbed woman. She needs help, and this is not how you give it to her.””

Gavin turned slowly.

“Then help me understand.””

Margaret looked at the guests.

“Everyone needs to leave.””

Nobody moved.

“I said leave!””

Patricia lowered her phone.

“Margaret, I think we should call the authorities.””

Margaret pointed at her.

“Stay out of my family.””

Then she looked at me.

“Elena. Take Noah inside.””

I held my son's hand.

He was crying quietly now.

“Mommy, is the lady coming out?””

I looked at the open staircase.

A pale hand appeared briefly at the bottom.

It clutched the railing.

Then disappeared.

I swallowed.

“Yes, sweetheart.””

For the first time in eleven years, I said something I actually believed.

“She is.””

Gavin started down the stairs.

One step.

Then another.

But before he reached the bottom, Molly called out again.

“Gavin?””

“I'm here.””

“Did you bring the newspaper?””

He stopped.

“What newspaper?””

“The one with the date.””

Gavin looked confused.

Molly's voice broke.

“Please tell me what year it is.””

He glanced at his phone.

“It's 2026.””

Silence.

Then a strangled sob.

“No…”

Gavin gripped the railing.

“What?””

“They told me it was still 2015.””

He looked up at the garden.

At Margaret.

At me.

May you like

And then he said something that made every guest turn toward his mother.

“Mom, what have you done?””

Related Stories

Other posts