wink
The Poison in Her Glass / Chapter 9 / 10

Chapter 9: The Inheritance of Lies

Brett didn't sleep that night.

He sat in a police interview room with the hospital recording playing repeatedly on a monitor.

Each time, he watched the same scene.

His father begging.

Ryan standing silently.

Daniel waiting near the door.

And Evelyn leaning over the hospital bed.

The woman who had taught Brett to drive.

The woman who had attended his wedding.

The woman who had sent flowers when his son was born.

She had been there when his father died.

And now she was claiming that George Mitchell had been hiding something about Brett's identity.

Officer Harris placed a cup of coffee on the table.

“Have you spoken to your mother since the recording?””

“No.””

“She may have information we need.””

Brett rubbed his eyes.

“She knew more than she admitted.””

“That's possible.””

“Do you think Evelyn is telling the truth?””

Officer Harris sat opposite him.

“I think she's trying to control the information you receive. That doesn't mean we should assume every statement she makes is false. But we need evidence.””

Brett nodded.

He looked at the frozen image of his father.

“Why would someone kill him over an inheritance?””

“Sometimes money isn't the only motive.””

Brett looked up.

“What else?””

“Control. Reputation. Fear of exposure.””

She paused.

“Your father may have known something that threatened more than a family business.””

Brett stared at the screen.

Then he remembered the final sentence in Evelyn's message.

Who your real father was.

He almost dismissed it.

But then he remembered something from childhood.

A conversation between his parents.

He had been nine.

He had walked into the kitchen one evening and heard his father shouting.

“Brett is my son, Margaret. Whatever happened before we married, he is my son.””

His mother had been crying.

When Brett entered, both adults had immediately stopped talking.

His father had knelt and hugged him.

“Never listen to anyone who tells you that you don't belong here,” George had said.

At the time, Brett thought it was about a schoolyard argument.

Now the memory returned with frightening clarity.

Officer Harris noticed his expression.

“What is it?””

“Nothing.””

“Mr. Mitchell.””

Brett looked at her.

“My aunt just told me my father wasn't my biological father.””

Harris remained quiet.

“Do you know anything about that?””

“No.””

He leaned back.

“That's the problem. Apparently, nobody in my family has ever told me the truth about anything.””

At ten the following morning, Brett received a call from Evelyn.

“Are you coming?””

“Where?””

“My house. Alone.””

“No.””

She sighed.

“Brett, I understand you're angry.””

“You don't understand anything.””

“I loved your father.””

“Then why were you in his hospital room?””

Silence.

“Where did you get that recording?””

“That's not important.””

“It is if you're planning to accuse me of something.””

“Did you help Ryan fake his death?””

Evelyn sighed again.

“Ryan was a troubled young man.””

“He was thirty-nine.””

“And still incapable of making sensible decisions.””

“Did you help him?””

“I helped the family.””

Brett almost laughed.

“That's what everyone says.””

Evelyn's voice softened.

“Come over. I'll show you the original will. I'll explain what your father was hiding.””

“I'm bringing the police.””

“Then don't bother coming.””

The line disconnected.

Brett looked at Officer Harris.

“She wants me alone.””

“Of course she does.””

“Can we get a warrant?””

“We're working on it. But if she has documents relevant to the investigation, we may be able to obtain them through the appropriate process.””

Brett stared at his phone.

Then another message arrived.

Not from Evelyn.

From Ryan.

*RYAN: Aunt Evelyn is lying to you. Ask her about the hospital's second patient.*

Brett read it twice.

A second patient?

He called Ryan.

The phone rang four times.

Then his brother answered.

“What now?””

“What second patient?””

Ryan laughed.

“So she told you about the hospital.””

“Who was the second patient?””

“You really want to know?””

“Yes.””

“Then ask Evelyn.””

“Stop playing games.””

Ryan's voice turned serious.

“Brett, our father wasn't the only person in that hospital room.””

“Who else?””

“Someone who shouldn't have been there.””

“Who?””

Ryan paused.

Then said:

“Your biological father.””

The call ended.

Brett sat motionless.

He looked at Officer Harris.

“Can you check my birth records?””

She frowned.

“Why?””

“Because I think someone has been lying about my parentage.””

An hour later, Brett sat in a small office with a legal representative and Officer Harris.

His original birth certificate listed George Mitchell as his father.

There was no indication of any discrepancy.

But the hospital records from his birth contained a note.

A paternity test had been requested.

The result was missing.

The request had been signed by George Mitchell.

And the second signature belonged to a doctor who had worked at the hospital where George later died.

Dr. Samuel Carter.

Brett stared at the name.

“Who is he?””

Officer Harris examined the document.

“According to the records, he retired twelve years ago.””

“Can we find him?””

“We can try.””

The legal representative turned another page.

“There is something else.””

Brett looked up.

“What?””

“The hospital's original records indicate that your mother was admitted under a different surname.””

“Which surname?””

“Carter.””

Brett felt his stomach drop.

He looked at the paper again.

His mother's maiden name had been Mitchell.

There was no reason for her to use Carter.

Unless…

“Was Dr. Samuel Carter married?””

The representative checked the records.

“Yes. But his wife died several years ago.””

Brett looked at Officer Harris.

“Can you find him?””

She nodded.

Dr. Samuel Carter lived in a quiet retirement community outside the city.

He agreed to meet Brett after Officer Harris explained that the inquiry concerned an old hospital record.

The doctor was in his late seventies, with thin white hair and a walking stick.

When Brett entered the room, Carter looked at him for several seconds.

Then he sighed.

“You look like George.””

Brett sat down.

“Did you know my father?””

“Very well.””

“Were you my mother's doctor?””

“Yes.””

“Did you perform a paternity test when I was born?””

Carter looked down.

“Yes.””

“Who was my biological father?””

The doctor took a long breath.

“I can't discuss another person's medical history without proper authorization.””

“Then look at me and tell me whether George Mitchell was my biological father.””

Carter closed his eyes.

“No.””

Brett felt the room disappear around him.

“Who was?””

The doctor hesitated.

Then he said:

“Your mother was involved with a man before she married George.””

“Who?””

“His name was Thomas Carter.””

Brett stared.

“Your brother?”” Officer Harris asked.

The doctor nodded.

“My younger brother.””

Brett couldn't speak.

“My mother had an affair with your brother?””

Carter shook his head.

“It wasn't an affair. George knew about it.””

“What?””

“Your mother and Thomas were together before she met George. When she discovered she was pregnant, Thomas disappeared. George offered to raise you as his own.””

Brett felt a strange mixture of anger and disbelief.

“Why would he do that?””

“Because he loved Margaret. And because he believed a child shouldn't pay for the mistakes of adults.””

Brett looked down.

“Did George know the truth?””

“Yes.””

“Did Ryan?””

Carter nodded.

“Your brother found out when he was twenty.””

“Why didn't anyone tell me?””

“Your father wanted to protect you.””

Brett laughed bitterly.

“Apparently, protecting me meant letting everyone lie to me for thirty-six years.””

Carter looked at him sadly.

“George wasn't perfect. But he loved you.””

Brett stared at the doctor.

“Did my biological father know about me?””

Carter hesitated.

Then he reached into a drawer.

He removed an old envelope.

“Your father gave me this shortly before he died.””

Brett took it.

Inside was a photograph.

A younger Margaret stood beside a man in a military uniform.

Thomas Carter.

On the back, someone had written:

*For Brett, when the time is right.*

There was also a letter.

Brett,

I have spent my entire life trying to give you the one thing I believed mattered most: a family.

Thomas was your biological father, but he was never the man who raised you. I was.

Ryan discovered the truth and used it against me. He threatened to expose your parentage unless I gave him control of the company.

I refused.

But there's something worse.

Thomas didn't simply disappear. He was paid to leave.

Brett stopped reading.

The final paragraph was underlined.

And the person who paid him was my sister, Evelyn.

Brett looked up.

“Why would she do that?””

Dr. Carter's expression became grave.

“Because Evelyn wanted George to marry Margaret.””

“Why?””

The doctor leaned forward.

“Because your father had inherited a fortune. Evelyn believed that if Margaret married him and gave him an heir, the family would remain under her control.””

Brett shook his head.

“That's insane.””

“Your aunt has always believed the Mitchell family belonged to her.””

Brett looked at the photograph.

Then he remembered the hospital recording.

Evelyn had been standing beside George's bed.

Not as a concerned sister.

As someone collecting what she believed belonged to her.

Officer Harris received a call.

She listened for several seconds, then looked at Brett.

“We have a problem.””

“What?””

“Your aunt's house has been searched.””

“By whom?””

“We don't know yet. But officers found blood in the study.””

Brett stood.

“Is Evelyn hurt?””

“We haven't located her.””

His phone vibrated.

A video message appeared.

It was from an unknown number.

Brett pressed play.

Evelyn sat in a chair, her hands tied behind her back.

Her face was bruised.

A man stood behind her.

He stepped into the light.

Ryan.

He looked directly into the camera.

“Brett, I warned you not to trust her.””

Then he pulled a chair beside Evelyn.

He leaned toward the lens.

“You wanted the truth about Dad? Fine. I'll give it to you.””

He paused.

“But before I do, you need to understand something.””

Ryan smiled.

“Evelyn didn't kill George.””

Brett stared at the screen.

Ryan continued.

“Neither did Cassie.””

He leaned closer.

“The person who gave Dad the final dose was the person he trusted most.””

The video ended.

Brett slowly lowered his phone.

Officer Harris asked, “Do you know what he means?””

Brett looked at the photograph of his mother and the old hospital documents.

Then his phone rang.

Margaret.

He answered immediately.

“Mom?””

Her voice was barely recognizable.

“Brett, please listen to me.””

“Where are you?””

“I need to tell you something before Ryan does.””

“What?””

A long pause.

Then she whispered:

“I was the one who gave your father the medication.””

Brett stopped breathing.

His mother began crying.

“I didn't know it would kill him.””

And before Brett could ask another question, she added:

“Your father asked me to do it.””

The call disconnected.

Brett stared at the screen.

May you like

For the first time since the glass shattered at dinner, he wondered whether the person he had been trying to save all along had been telling the truth.

Or whether the entire family had been built on one final, terrible lie.

Related Stories

Other posts