wink

Chapter 1: The Empty Roasting Pan

The first thing my boyfriend’s mother said when I walked into her Thanksgiving dinner was, “Nina, where on earth is the turkey?””

I was standing in her marble-floored foyer, holding an empty roasting pan with both hands.

And before I could answer, she looked me up and down and added, “You know, if you’re going to marry into this family, you need to learn that we don’t arrive empty-handed.””

I blinked.

“My name is Nora,” I said quietly.

Behind her, my boyfriend, Ethan, stopped adjusting his cufflinks.

For one brief second, his eyes met mine.

Then he looked away.

That was when I realized Thanksgiving was going to be very different from what he had promised.

Three hours earlier, I had been standing in my apartment kitchen, trying to decide whether the cranberry sauce needed another five minutes.

My phone buzzed on the counter.

*Ethan:*

Don't forget Mom's roasting pan. Bring it with you tonight.

I frowned at the message.

*Me:*

The big silver one?

*Ethan:*

Yeah. She needs it for the turkey.

*Me:*

Should I bring anything else? Dessert? Wine?

His reply came almost immediately.

*Ethan:*

No. Just the pan. I'll explain when you get here.

I had been dating Ethan for fourteen months.

Fourteen months of Sunday breakfasts, late-night conversations, weekend trips, and conversations about what our future might look like.

He had recently started talking about marriage.

Not directly, of course.

Ethan was the kind of man who preferred to drop hints and watch people react.

He had once pointed at a house during a drive and said, "I could see us living somewhere like that.""

Another time, while we were shopping for groceries, he had picked up a jar of expensive pasta sauce and said, "This is the kind of thing you buy when you're cooking for a family.""

I had laughed.

But secretly, I had started imagining what a family with Ethan might look like.

His mother, Margaret, was the one complication.

She had never been openly cruel to me.

Instead, she specialized in little comments that could always be explained away.

She called my apartment "cozy" in the same tone someone might use for a storage closet.

She once asked whether my job in marketing was "a real career or something temporary.""

And at our first family dinner, she had spent twenty minutes showing me photographs of Ethan's former girlfriend.

Nina.

Beautiful, polished Nina.

Nina, who had gone to the same private university as Ethan.

Nina, whose father owned a chain of luxury car dealerships.

Nina, who apparently knew how to arrange flowers, select wine, and prepare Thanksgiving dinner for twenty people without breaking a sweat.

Margaret mentioned her so often that I eventually asked Ethan whether his mother was still close to her.

He had laughed.

"Mom has trouble letting go," he said.

"Don't take it personally.""

So I tried not to.

I bought Margaret birthday flowers.

I remembered her favorite tea.

I even learned how to make the pecan pie she once mentioned missing from her childhood.

She thanked me with a tight smile and asked whether Ethan liked it as much as Nina's.

I had told myself that winning Margaret over wasn't important.

I was dating Ethan, not his mother.

But that afternoon, as I carried the empty roasting pan toward the front door, I had a strange feeling in my stomach.

I almost texted Ethan again.

Instead, I put on my coat and left.

His parents lived in an enormous colonial house in an affluent neighborhood outside Boston. White pillars framed the entrance, golden lights glowed through the windows, and two perfectly trimmed evergreen wreaths hung on the double doors.

Cars lined the driveway.

I recognized Ethan's black Mercedes.

I also noticed a white SUV parked beside it.

I didn't recognize that one.

I rang the bell.

Margaret opened the door before I could knock twice.

She wore a burgundy silk dress, diamond earrings, and the expression of a woman who had just discovered a stain on an expensive rug.

"Nina!"" she exclaimed.

Then she looked at the empty roasting pan.

Her smile disappeared.

"Where is the turkey?""

I took a breath.

"Hello, Margaret. I'm Nora.""

She stared at me.

For a moment, she seemed genuinely confused.

Then she gave a small, dismissive laugh.

"Oh. Of course. Nora.""

She stepped aside.

"Well, come in. You're holding up the doorway.""

I entered.

The house smelled of roasted garlic, cinnamon, butter, and something expensive burning in the fireplace.

Guests filled the living room.

Ethan's father, Richard, was pouring wine near the dining room entrance. His older sister, Claire, stood beside the kitchen island, arranging silverware.

Several people turned to look at me.

Margaret pointed toward the kitchen.

"Put that down. The turkey should have been here twenty minutes ago.""

I looked at the empty pan.

Then back at her.

"Actually, Ethan asked me to bring this.""

Margaret's eyebrows rose.

"Excuse me?""

"The roasting pan. He said you needed it.""

She stared at me as if I had announced that I had brought a dead animal instead of dinner.

"You're telling me you came all this way with an empty dish?""

Before I could answer, Ethan appeared behind her.

He looked handsome in a navy sweater and pressed trousers.

His hair was perfectly styled.

He was holding a glass of wine.

"Hey, babe.""

I felt a little relief.

Finally, someone who knew what was happening.

"Hi," I said.

"Your mother seems confused about the pan.""

Ethan glanced at it.

Then he leaned close enough that only I could hear him.

"You were supposed to drop off the pan.""

I stared at him.

"What?""

He lowered his voice further.

"Just put it in the kitchen. Don't make this awkward.""

I looked at him for several seconds.

"You're the one who told me to bring it.""

"I know. I just meant—"

Margaret interrupted.

"Honestly, Ethan, I don't understand why you couldn't have asked someone more organized.""

He took a sip of wine.

"Mom, it's fine.""

It wasn't fine.

Not even close.

I carried the roasting pan into the dining room and placed it on the long mahogany table.

It landed with a hollow metallic sound.

A few guests looked over.

Claire approached me.

"Hey, Nora. Everything okay?""

I gave her a small smile.

"Apparently, I misunderstood the assignment.""

She glanced at the empty pan.

Then at her brother.

Something in her expression changed.

Before she could say anything, Margaret clapped her hands.

"Everyone, dinner will be ready shortly. We're just waiting for one more person.""

I looked at Ethan.

"One more person?""

He didn't answer.

Instead, he checked his watch.

And for the first time that evening, I noticed something strange.

He wasn't surprised that I had arrived.

He was waiting for something.

Or someone.

I moved closer to him.

"Is there something you haven't told me?""

He gave me a quick smile.

"Can we not do this right now?""

"Do what?""

"Question everything.""

I folded my arms.

"Ethan, you asked me to bring an empty roasting pan to your family's Thanksgiving dinner. Your mother thinks I'm someone else. And now we're waiting for another guest. I think a little explanation is reasonable.""

He glanced toward the front door.

"Just trust me.""

I wanted to ask him what that meant.

But before I could, three sharp knocks echoed through the house.

Margaret's face lit up.

"Oh! She's here!""

Ethan straightened his sweater.

His father put down his wineglass.

Claire stopped arranging the silverware.

And my boyfriend, the man who had been telling me for months that I was the woman he wanted to marry, smiled at the front door like he had been waiting all evening for this exact moment.

Margaret hurried toward the entrance.

I remained beside the dining table.

Then I heard her delighted voice.

"Nina, sweetheart! Finally!""

And the sound of someone carrying a heavy dish into the house.

I turned toward the doorway.

The woman standing there was holding a magnificent golden-brown turkey.

She wore a cream-colored coat, elegant black boots, and a diamond bracelet that caught the light.

Her hair fell in soft waves over her shoulders.

She looked exactly like the photographs Margaret had shown me.

Nina.

May you like

Ethan's ex-girlfriend.

And she was staring directly at me.

Related Stories

Other posts