wink

Chapter 5: Two Fathers, One Terrible Lie

The second laboratory report remained on the vanity.

Nobody touched it.

Maya stood motionless, still wearing her wedding dress.

I could hear the faint sound of guests leaving the ballroom. Someone was moving chairs. Somewhere, a glass shattered.

But inside that small room, time seemed to have stopped.

"Read it," Maya whispered.

Nicole carefully picked up the report.

"The test was conducted at a different laboratory. It identifies Richard Bennett as the tested individual and records a probability of paternity of 99.98 percent.""

Maya blinked.

"Then Richard is my father?""

Nicole nodded slowly.

"According to this report, yes. But we need to authenticate both documents and establish whether the samples were correctly identified.""

Maya let out a breath.

"So my mother told me the truth about Richard?""

"Possibly," Nicole replied.

"But that doesn't explain the other report.""

I looked at the two documents.

One identified Daniel as Maya's biological father.

The other identified Richard.

Both appeared legitimate.

Both carried laboratory seals.

And both had been preserved in my father's estate records.

"Could someone have switched the samples?"" I asked.

Nicole nodded.

"It's possible. We need the original laboratory files, chain-of-custody records, and the identities of the people who submitted the samples.""

Maya sat on the edge of the vanity.

"Why would anyone do that?""

Nobody answered.

Then Harriet appeared in the doorway.

She looked exhausted.

Her makeup had begun to run, and the elegant composure she usually wore like armor was gone.

"Maya, please. We need to talk.""

Maya didn't look up.

"Which version of the truth are you bringing today?""

Harriet flinched.

"I understand that you're angry.""

"You're right. I'm angry.""

"Your father and I made mistakes.""

"Which father?""

Harriet lowered her head.

I stepped between them.

"Harriet, we need answers. Not another speech about how difficult your life was.""

She looked at me.

"You have no idea what I sacrificed.""

"Then explain the two reports.""

Harriet glanced at Nicole.

"That second report is meaningless.""

"Why?""

"Because the first test was conducted incorrectly.""

Nicole frowned.

"Do you have evidence?""

Harriet hesitated.

"I have the original correspondence.""

"Where?""

Harriet looked toward her purse.

Then she slowly removed a folded piece of paper.

"I kept this because I knew someone would eventually use the test against me.""

Nicole accepted it.

The letter was from a laboratory administrator.

It stated that the first sample had been submitted through an intermediary and that the laboratory could not independently verify the identity of the donor.

The second report had been commissioned directly by Richard.

Nicole read the final paragraph twice.

"This means the first report cannot establish Daniel's paternity conclusively.""

Maya looked at Harriet.

"Then why did you let everyone believe it?""

Harriet's voice broke.

"Because Daniel believed it.""

I frowned.

"What?""

"He thought you were his daughter. He wanted you to be. And I was afraid that if I challenged him, he would take you away from me.""

Richard appeared behind her.

"He never wanted to take Maya away.""

Harriet turned.

"You don't know what he said to me.""

"I know what he wrote.""

Richard took another document from Nicole's binder.

"Daniel sent me this letter shortly before he died.""

He handed it to Maya.

She unfolded it.

The letter was dated six weeks before Daniel's death.

Richard, I know what happened between Harriet and me. I also know you have raised Maya as your own. I have no intention of taking that away from you.

If the test confirms I am her biological father, I will acknowledge it. If it does not, I will still make sure she has a future protected from the mistakes we adults have made.

She deserves two men who care about her, not a lifetime of arguments over who owns the title of father.

Maya pressed the letter against her chest.

"Why didn't anyone show me this?""

Richard looked ashamed.

"Because Harriet convinced me that telling you would destroy our family.""

Maya laughed bitterly.

"Apparently keeping the secret worked out wonderfully.""

Harriet sat down.

For several seconds, she stared at her hands.

Then she finally began telling the story.

She explained that she and Richard had been struggling with infertility when they were married.

They had undergone several medical procedures, but none had worked.

At the same time, Harriet's business was collapsing under the weight of unpaid loans.

Daniel had become one of her closest friends.

He offered financial assistance.

He also offered to help them find a specialist.

During that period, Harriet had become pregnant.

She had never been entirely certain whether Richard was the biological father.

Daniel believed there was a possibility that he was.

Richard had agreed to raise the child regardless.

But when Daniel later requested a paternity test, Harriet panicked.

She feared losing Richard.

She feared losing Daniel's financial support.

And she feared that the truth would destroy her carefully constructed life.

"So you arranged two different tests?"" I asked.

Harriet nodded.

"The first was arranged through someone I knew. The second was requested by Richard.""

"Did you manipulate the first sample?""

Harriet looked down.

"I don't remember.""

Nicole's voice became sharp.

"You don't remember whether you submitted an authenticated sample?""

Harriet sighed.

"I was under enormous pressure.""

Maya stood.

"You keep saying that. But you were never the only person under pressure. You made decisions for everyone.""

Harriet began crying.

"I was trying to keep you safe.""

"No, Mom. You were trying to keep yourself safe.""

That sentence silenced the room.

Then Richard stepped closer.

"There's another reason I kept quiet.""

Maya looked at him.

He reached into his jacket and removed a small photograph.

It showed Richard holding a newborn baby.

On the back was a date and a handwritten message.

The day I became a father.

Richard smiled sadly.

"I wrote that the day you were born.""

Maya began crying again.

"Did you know I might not be yours?""

"Yes.""

"And you stayed?""

Richard nodded.

"I held you in that hospital room. You wrapped your tiny fingers around mine, and I knew I was your father. Nothing that came afterward changed that.""

Maya walked toward him.

Then she embraced him.

Richard held her tightly.

I looked away, trying to give them a moment.

For the first time that day, I understood that the truth wasn't necessarily the same thing as the family.

A family could be built through love.

But love couldn't survive forever when it was forced to live inside lies.

Nicole's phone rang.

She checked the screen.

"Excuse me.""

She stepped into the hallway.

A minute later, she returned.

"Ethan, I've spoken to the laboratory's legal department. They can release the original testing records, but they need authorization from the individuals involved.""

Maya nodded.

"Do whatever is necessary.""

Nicole looked at Richard.

"Mr. Bennett?""

He agreed immediately.

Then she turned toward Harriet.

Harriet hesitated.

"Why should I sign anything?""

Maya looked at her mother.

"Because I'm asking you.""

Harriet stared at her daughter for several seconds.

Then she signed.

Nicole collected the papers.

"I'll arrange the verification.""

I thought that was the end of the discussion.

It wasn't.

As Nicole returned to her seat, Margaret entered the bridal room.

She was holding a small velvet box.

"Ethan," she said softly, "I think you should have this.""

I recognized the box.

It had belonged to my father.

My mother opened it.

Inside was a gold pocket watch.

I remembered it from my childhood. Daniel used to carry it everywhere.

I picked it up.

"Why do you have this?""

"Your father gave it to me before he died.""

She opened the back cover.

A tiny folded piece of paper was hidden inside.

I carefully removed it.

There was a handwritten message.

Margaret, if the original agreement is ever discovered, give Ethan the watch. The key to the truth is not in the bank records. It is in the building.

I looked at my mother.

"What building?""

"The property on the north side.""

Nicole immediately approached.

"Did Daniel ever tell you what he meant?""

Margaret nodded.

"He said there was a locked office on the second floor. He kept certain original documents there.""

"Why didn't you tell us earlier?""

"Because I thought the building had been emptied years ago.""

Nicole looked at the watch again.

"Is there a key?""

Margaret turned the watch over.

A tiny metal key was hidden beneath the inner mechanism.

I stared at it.

My father had left us another clue.

Harriet suddenly stood.

"That building is no longer yours.""

I turned toward her.

"According to the records, it belongs to my father's estate.""

"Not anymore.""

Nicole frowned.

"What do you mean?""

Harriet picked up her purse.

"The building was transferred to a third party.""

"When?""

"Six months ago.""

My heart began pounding.

"Who bought it?""

Harriet looked directly at me.

"Someone who knows exactly what happened eighteen years ago.""

She walked toward the door.

Nicole blocked her.

"Mrs. Bennett, we aren't finished.""

Harriet raised her voice.

"Move!""

Richard stepped forward.

"Harriet, stop making this worse.""

She turned toward him.

"You think you're innocent? You signed the original transfer agreement too!""

Richard froze.

I looked at him.

"What?""

Harriet smiled bitterly.

"Ask your future father-in-law why his signature appears on the authorization.""

Richard's face went pale.

Maya released his hand.

"Is that true?""

Richard didn't answer immediately.

Then he nodded.

"Yes.""

Maya stared at him.

"Why?""

He looked at me.

"Because Daniel asked me to.""

Nicole opened the binder again.

"Then we need to see that authorization.""

Richard lowered his eyes.

"I can show you.""

He turned toward the door.

"But first, there's something you need to know about the man who bought the building.""

He paused.

"His name is Thomas Reed.""

Nicole's face changed.

"The accountant from the photograph?""

Richard nodded.

"He's alive. And he's the only person who knows what happened to the original trust.""

I looked at the gold watch in my hand.

Then at Harriet.

She was no longer smiling.

Because she knew that if Thomas Reed returned, the last eighteen years of her carefully protected secrets might finally collapse.

And before anyone could ask another question, my phone rang.

The caller ID showed an unfamiliar Arizona number.

I answered.

May you like

A man's voice came through.

"Mr. Carter? My name is Thomas Reed. I've been waiting a long time to speak with you.""

Related Stories

Other posts