wink

Chapter 4: The Secret of the First Mrs. Whitmore

Graham read the message three times before he could make sense of it.

*Ask your mother what happened to the first Mrs. Whitmore.*

His mother.

Margaret.

The woman who had baked his birthday cakes, held his hand through childhood illnesses, and cried harder than anyone at his wedding.

The woman who had spent the entire evening pretending to be horrified by Claire's revelations.

He slowly raised his eyes toward the staircase.

“Detective Harris?””

“Yes?””

“Where is my mother?””

“Upstairs, I believe.””

Graham shook his head.

“No. I need you to find her.””

The detective studied him.

“Mr. Whitmore, we have officers outside. Nobody is leaving this property without being questioned.””

“That's not what I mean. I need to know where she is right now.””

Detective Harris signaled to one of the officers.

“Check the upstairs rooms.””

Graham walked toward the staircase.

“Graham!”” Daniel called from above.

He turned.

His younger brother was standing at the landing, holding Ari.

“What's happening?””

“Where's Mom?””

Daniel frowned.

“She was in the kitchen a minute ago.””

“Did you see her leave?””

“No.””

Graham climbed the stairs two at a time.

The kitchen was empty.

A cup of tea sat beside the sink, still steaming.

On the counter was Margaret's handbag.

Her phone was missing.

Graham checked the garden doors.

Locked.

Then he noticed something strange.

The small window beside the pantry was open.

Cold air moved through the curtains.

“Daniel!””

His brother appeared behind him.

“What?””

“Did Mom ever mention a woman named Eleanor?””

Daniel frowned.

“Eleanor who?””

“Eleanor Whitmore.””

The color drained from Daniel's face.

Graham noticed immediately.

“You know that name.””

Daniel looked toward the staircase.

“Not here.””

“Tell me.””

“Graham, please.””

“Lila is missing. Claire has been lying. Dad has disappeared.

Someone just sent me a photograph of my wife tied to a chair. I don't have time for whatever family secret you're protecting.””

Daniel rubbed his face.

“Eleanor was Dad's first wife.””

Graham stared at him.

“I know that much.””

“She didn't die in an accident.””

The kitchen seemed to grow colder.

“What?””

Daniel lowered his voice.

“Dad told us she left him. I found something when I was seventeen. A newspaper clipping in his study.””

“What did it say?””

“That Eleanor disappeared in 1989. Her car was found near the river, but her body was never recovered.””

Graham gripped the countertop.

“Why didn't you tell me?””

“Because Mom made me promise not to.””

“Mom?””

Daniel nodded.

“She told me Dad had threatened her. She said Eleanor had discovered something about the family business, and Dad wouldn't let her leave.””

Graham stared at him.

For years, he had believed his father was a difficult but honorable man.

Now he wondered how many lies had been built into the foundations of his childhood.

“Did Mom say what happened to Eleanor?””

Daniel shook his head.

“She only said that if Dad ever started talking about protecting the family, we should run.””

Before Graham could respond, Detective Harris entered the kitchen.

“Mr. Whitmore, we have a problem.””

“What?””

“Your mother isn't upstairs.””

Graham pointed toward the open pantry window.

“She left.””

“We found her car near the eastern gate. The driver-side door was open.””

“Did anyone see her?””

“One of the officers saw a vehicle leaving the property about five minutes ago. We have its registration.””

“Whose car?””

The detective checked his notes.

“Registered to a woman named Eleanor Whitmore.””

Graham felt his knees weaken.

“That isn't possible.””

Detective Harris looked at him.

“Why?””

“Because Eleanor Whitmore disappeared thirty-seven years ago.””

The detective's expression changed.

“Then we have a much bigger problem than we thought.””

At 10:46 p.m., Graham received another call.

This time, the number was private.

He answered immediately.

“Where is my wife?””

For several seconds, there was only breathing.

Then a woman's voice whispered:

“Graham?””

He nearly dropped the phone.

“Lila?””

“Don't say my name too loudly.””

“Baby, where are you?””

“Listen to me. You have to get Ari out of that house.””

Graham closed his eyes.

“Are you hurt?””

A shaky breath came through the speaker.

“Yes.””

“Tell me where you are. I'll come get you.””

“No. You can't.””

“Lila, I'm coming.””

“Graham, please. Your mother knows.””

He looked at Detective Harris.

“Knows what?””

“About the room. About Eleanor. About everything.””

“Who has you?””

A pause.

Then Lila whispered something that made his heart stop.

“Your father isn't working alone.””

Graham gripped the phone.

“Who else?””

Before she could answer, a man's voice sounded in the background.

“Lila, put that down.””

She gasped.

“Graham, if you find the old ledger, you'll understand why they—”

The call ended.

Graham immediately called back.

The number was unavailable.

He turned toward the detective.

“We need to find her.””

“We're tracing the call.””

“Do it faster.””

Detective Harris was about to respond when Daniel rushed into the kitchen.

“Graham!””

“What?””

“Ari's asking for you.””

“I'll be there in a minute.””

“No. You need to see this.””

Daniel held out Ari's pink bunny.

Its small fabric belly had been torn open.

Inside was a folded photograph.

Graham unfolded it.

The picture showed a much younger Margaret standing beside a dark-haired woman.

Behind them was a man Graham recognized as his father.

On the back, someone had written:

*Eleanor, Margaret, and Lila. Three women. One family secret.*

Graham stared at the photograph.

Then he noticed the date.

June 14, 1989.

The same date Eleanor had disappeared.

He turned it over again.

There was something else written beneath the first message.

A single sentence.

*Ask which woman gave birth to the boy called Graham.*

His fingers went numb.

Daniel looked at him.

“What does that mean?””

Graham couldn't answer.

Because at that moment, a memory came rushing back.

He was six years old, standing in the upstairs hallway.

His father was arguing with Margaret.

And his mother was crying.

He remembered Richard shouting:

“You promised me you would never tell him!””

Then Margaret had looked directly at Graham.

May you like

And whispered:

“Some day, sweetheart, you'll understand why I had to pretend.””

Related Stories

Other posts