wink

Chapter 1: The Dinner for Two

At 7:43 p.m. on our fifth wedding anniversary, I heard my husband tell my younger sister that he hated being married to me.

Then I heard her laugh.

She told him not to worry because I would be waiting at home, probably sitting beside the anniversary dinner I'd prepared myself.

What neither of them knew was that I could hear every word.

And I was about to discover that the two people I trusted most had already planned a life without me.

The candles were burning too low.

I noticed that first.

One of the ivory candles I'd placed beside the flowers had begun dripping wax onto the white tablecloth. I hurried over and adjusted it, careful not to disturb the arrangement.

Five years.

Five years of marriage to Evan Mitchell.

Five years of anniversaries, birthdays, holidays, and ordinary Tuesday evenings when we'd promised each other that no matter how difficult life became, we'd always come home to one another.

Tonight was supposed to be special.

I'd prepared his favorite meal: rosemary-crusted steak, garlic mashed potatoes, roasted asparagus, and the chocolate cake from the little bakery where we'd celebrated our first anniversary.

There were two glasses of red wine on the table.

Two folded napkins.

Two handwritten cards.

And a small velvet box containing a silver watch I'd spent three months saving for.

I checked the time again.

7:45 p.m.

Evan had promised to be home by seven.

I picked up my phone and looked at our last messages.

*Me, 4:12 p.m.:* Don't forget tonight. I've got a surprise for you.

*Evan, 4:18 p.m.:* Wouldn't miss it. Love you.

I smiled at that message earlier.

Now, looking at it, I felt a strange little knot forming in my stomach.

I called him.

He answered after four rings.

"What?""

His voice was sharp enough to make me pull the phone away from my ear.

"Hey, it's me.""

"I know it's you, Rachel.""

I glanced at the clock.

"I was just wondering whether you're on your way home. Dinner's ready, and I don't want everything getting cold.""

A sigh.

A loud, irritated sigh.

"Seriously? You're checking up on me again?""

I blinked.

"Checking up on you?""

"Rachel, I'm at work. I've told you I have things to finish.""

"I know. I just thought you said you'd be home by seven.""

"Well, things change.""

There was something unusual about his voice.

Not just irritation.

He sounded distracted, almost as though he were trying to keep someone from hearing our conversation.

I lowered my voice.

"Okay. I wasn't trying to pressure you. I just wanted to know when to put the food back in the oven.""

"Then put it back in the oven.""

A pause.

"And stop calling me every five minutes. It's exhausting.""

My fingers tightened around the phone.

"I called once, Evan.""

"Whatever. I have to go.""

"Happy anniversary, by the way.""

Silence.

Then he muttered, "Yeah. Happy anniversary.""

I heard a clinking sound.

A fork against a plate, perhaps.

Then the faint scrape of a chair.

"Evan?""

"What?""

"Are you somewhere noisy?""

"I'm in the office cafeteria.""

I frowned.

The office cafeteria?

He'd told me last week that the cafeteria closed at six.

But perhaps he'd forgotten something.

Perhaps I was overthinking.

"All right. I'll leave your plate covered.""

"Fine.""

He didn't hang up.

Instead, I heard a muffled sound, followed by what seemed like the rustling of fabric.

"Evan? Are you still there?""

No answer.

I looked at the screen.

The call was still connected.

I was about to say goodbye when his voice came through again, clearer this time.

"God, she's unbelievable.""

I froze.

There was a moment of silence.

Then a woman's voice.

"What's wrong now?""

My heart gave one hard, uncomfortable beat.

I knew that voice.

I knew it better than almost anyone.

It belonged to Lily.

My younger sister.

I stood completely still.

"Evan, you're going to have to stop answering her calls like that," Lily said.

"She'll start getting suspicious.""

"Suspicious of what?"" Evan replied.

"She thinks I'm at work. That's all she needs to know.""

I slowly lowered myself into the dining chair.

The candles flickered.

The food smelled wonderful.

And suddenly, the entire house felt unfamiliar.

Lily laughed softly.

"Did she ask when you'd be home?""

"Of course she did. She's been doing that all week.""

"Well, you did promise her an anniversary dinner.""

"Don't remind me.""

I pressed my free hand against my mouth.

Evan continued.

"Five years, Lily. Five years of pretending everything is fine. I'm sick of it.""

My eyes drifted toward the little velvet box beside my plate.

The watch.

The gift I'd bought him.

Lily's voice softened.

"Then don't pretend anymore.""

"You make it sound easy.""

"It is easy. You just need to stop feeling guilty.""

Evan let out a humorless laugh.

"Guilty? I'm the one who's been trapped in that marriage.""

Trapped.

That word landed harder than I expected.

I looked around the dining room.

The framed wedding photograph.

The little ceramic house we'd bought on our honeymoon.

The family portraits on the shelf.

Was this what he saw when he looked at our life?

A prison?

Lily spoke again.

"She'll be fine.""

"You don't know that.""

"Rachel always lands on her feet. Besides, she has that house, her job, and all those friends who think she's perfect. She'll survive.""

I closed my eyes.

My sister knew exactly how hard I'd worked to build my life.

She knew about the years I'd spent helping Evan establish his architecture firm.

She knew how many nights I'd stayed awake reviewing his proposals because he was too exhausted to finish them.

She knew I'd postponed a promotion once because he needed someone to support him during the early years of his business.

And she knew I'd defended him when our parents questioned whether he was taking too much from me.

I had defended him.

I had defended her, too.

When Lily's relationship with her former boyfriend collapsed, I'd let her stay in our guest room for four months.

When she lost her job, I'd helped her pay rent.

When she said she felt lonely, I'd invited her on our family vacations.

She'd sat beside me at my wedding.

She'd held my bouquet.

She'd cried when Evan kissed me.

Now she was sitting across from him, discussing how easily I'd be discarded.

"Evan," Lily said, "you promised me something.""

"What?""

"That after tonight, we're done pretending.""

He sighed.

"I know.""

"Good. Because I'm tired of sneaking around.""

I stared at the phone.

Sneaking around.

The words were so ordinary.

So casual.

As though they were discussing a restaurant reservation.

Then Evan said something that made my entire body go cold.

"I hate her, Lily. I hate coming home and pretending I love her. I hate listening to her talk about our future. I hate everything about this marriage.""

I stopped breathing.

For several seconds, I couldn't even hear the refrigerator humming in the kitchen.

Lily didn't sound shocked.

She didn't sound offended.

She sounded pleased.

"Then tonight is your last night pretending," she whispered.

I looked at the phone again.

The call was still active.

My thumb hovered over the screen.

I could have ended it.

I could have thrown the phone against the wall.

I could have called my mother and screamed until I couldn't speak.

Instead, I placed the phone on the table.

I tapped the speaker button.

And I listened.

Evan shifted in his chair.

"Your sister will wait for me," he said.

Lily laughed.

"Of course she will.""

"She's probably got the whole house decorated.""

"She does love making everything perfect.""

"That's the problem. Everything with Rachel is a performance.""

Lily made a small sound of agreement.

Then she said something that made my blood run cold.

"She'll wait because she helped set the table herself. Remember? She was so excited about tonight.""

I stared at the empty chair opposite mine.

My sister had helped me choose the flowers three days earlier.

She'd stood in my kitchen, tasted the chocolate frosting, and told me Evan was a lucky man.

She'd even suggested the candles.

And now she was using those same details to mock me.

I leaned closer to the phone.

"Tell me something, Lily.""

My voice came out barely above a whisper, although neither of them could hear me.

"How long?""

There was no answer.

Of course there wasn't.

They didn't know I was listening.

Then Lily asked, "Are we still leaving together after dinner?""

My fingers went numb.

Evan answered without hesitation.

"Yes.""

"Your bags are already in my car.""

"I know.""

"Everything?""

"Everything I need.""

I stared at the phone.

His bags.

In my sister's car.

I remembered Evan saying he was going to take some clothes to the dry cleaner yesterday.

I remembered Lily borrowing my spare car key because she said she'd left hers at our parents' house.

I remembered the strange conversation I'd overheard two weeks earlier, when Lily asked Evan whether he preferred the blue suitcase or the black one.

I'd assumed she was helping him choose luggage for a business trip.

I had been so painfully, embarrassingly trusting.

I picked up my phone and brought it closer.

"Lily?""

My voice was quiet.

Neither of them responded.

"Lily, why do you have my husband's bags in your car?""

Silence.

A chair scraped against the floor.

Then I heard Evan's voice.

"Wait.""

Another pause.

"Wait a minute.""

His breathing changed.

I imagined him looking down at his phone.

Seeing my name.

Seeing the call duration.

Seeing that the call he'd never bothered to end was still connected.

"Rachel?""

For the first time that evening, he sounded afraid.

I looked at the anniversary cake.

The five candles I'd arranged around it.

The gift.

The photographs.

Then I asked the question that had been burning inside me since the moment I recognized my sister's voice.

"Evan, are you leaving with Lily tonight?""

I heard him draw a breath.

May you like

And then—

The line went silent.

Related Stories

Other posts