wink

Chapter 8: The Photograph That Should Never Have Existed

I reached my mother's bedroom before anyone could stop me.

Madison was standing beside the wardrobe, her phone trembling in her hand. The wedding dress was gone. She had changed into a cream blouse and black trousers, and the pearls lay on the dresser beside an overturned jewelry box.

Her face was white.

“Olivia,” she whispered.

I followed her gaze.

On the bed lay a photograph.

It showed my mother standing outside St. Agnes Fertility Center, holding a newborn baby. Beside her stood Alexander Hayes, the scar on his cheek visible even in the grainy image.

Someone had drawn a red circle around the baby's face.

Beneath it, in black ink, were four words.

*SHE WAS NEVER YOURS.*

I stepped closer.

My stomach twisted.

“Where did you find this?””

“On the bed.””

“When?””

“About ten minutes ago.””

“Was anyone here?””

Madison shook her head.

“I came in to look for the jewelry box. I thought if I returned the pearls, maybe Richard would stop threatening Dad. Then I saw this.””

She pointed to the photograph.

“I swear I didn't put it there.””

I studied her face.

For once, she didn't look calculating or smug. She looked like a frightened young woman who had wandered into a story she didn't understand.

“Did you tell Mom?”” I asked.

“She isn't answering her phone.””

Victoria appeared in the doorway.

“Madison, come here.””

Madison rushed toward her mother.

“Mom, what's happening?””

Victoria wrapped her arms around her daughter.

“Nothing you need to worry about.””

Madison pulled away.

“Don't lie to me! Dad is acting like he's going to prison, Richard Blackwood is threatening to freeze our accounts, and now someone is leaving creepy photographs in this house. What is going on?””

Victoria looked at me.

I held her gaze.

“Tell her.””

“Olivia—”

“She's involved whether you admit it or not. She wore Mom's dress in front of four hundred people. Someone is using Mom's belongings to send messages. Madison deserves to know why.””

Madison stared at me.

For once, she didn't argue.

Victoria sat on the edge of the bed.

“Your father, Alexander Hayes, was a dangerous man.””

Madison flinched.

“Don't call him that.””

Victoria looked startled.

“What?””

“You always told me my biological father died in a boating accident. You said he was a wonderful man who loved me, but that I was too young to remember him.””

Victoria's expression crumpled.

“I was trying to protect you.””

“From what?””

“From the truth.””

Madison laughed bitterly.

“Everyone in this family says that.””

She looked at me.

“I hated you because I thought you had everything. Daniel loved you. You had the house, the photographs, the memories. Even after your mother died, everyone treated you like you were made of glass.””

Her voice trembled.

“And I was supposed to be grateful that your father let us live here.””

I felt a painful knot form in my chest.

“Madison, I never asked you to compete with me.””

“No. You just looked at me like I didn't belong.””

I wanted to deny it.

But I remembered the years of arguments, the contempt I had felt whenever she entered my mother's room, the way I had treated her as an intruder even when she was trying to find her place in a family that had never truly welcomed her.

“I was angry,” I admitted.

“But I shouldn't have made you feel like you had to prove you belonged.””

Madison looked away.

Then she glanced at the photograph.

“Do you think Alexander is alive?””

I didn't answer.

Victoria rose.

“We need to call the police.””

“No,” Daniel said from the doorway.

He had followed us upstairs, his face drawn and exhausted.

“Absolutely not.””

Victoria turned on him.

“Someone entered the house and left a threatening message. We are calling the police.””

“And telling them what? That a man who has been legally dead for eleven years may be alive? That we have been hiding medical records? That Eleanor's death may not have been what we believed?””

“Yes,” I said.

“Exactly that.””

Daniel looked at me.

“You have no idea what you're inviting into this house.””

I stepped toward him.

“Then tell me what happened to Mom.””

He stared at the photograph.

For a long time, he said nothing.

Finally, he sat down beside the wardrobe.

“Three days before Eleanor died, she called me from the hospital. She told me she had discovered that Alexander's death certificate might be false.””

I felt the air leave my lungs.

“How?””

“She had received an anonymous package containing a copy of a bank transfer and a photograph. The transfer was from a company connected to Alexander to a private account opened under another name. The photograph showed a man leaving a hotel in Boston two days after the supposed boating accident.””

“Did you see the photograph?””

“Yes.””

“Do you still have it?””

Daniel nodded.

“It's in my study.””

I looked at Victoria.

She seemed to be struggling to breathe.

“Did Mom believe Alexander was alive?””

“She believed it was possible. She wanted to investigate, but her health was deteriorating. I told her to leave it alone.””

“Why?””

“Because I was afraid he would come after you.””

I stared at him.

“And what did Mom say?””

Daniel's eyes filled with tears.

“She said she would rather die knowing the truth than live another day believing she had failed to protect her daughter.””

The room fell silent.

I looked at the photograph on the bed.

My mother had known something was wrong. She had been trying to uncover the truth even as her health failed.

And everyone around her had tried to silence her in the name of protecting me.

I was beginning to understand why she had left so many letters.

She hadn't trusted anyone to tell the story after she was gone.

“Get the photograph from your study,” I said.

Daniel stood.

“Olivia—”

“Please.””

He looked at me for a long moment.

Then he left.

Victoria sat down again, her hands trembling.

Madison stood beside her, staring at the pearls.

After a minute, she picked them up.

“I should never have worn these.””

I looked at her.

“No. You shouldn't have.””

She winced.

“I know.””

She held the necklace out to me.

“I'm sorry.””

The apology was so unexpected that I couldn't respond immediately.

Madison lowered her eyes.

“I wanted everyone to think I was special. I wanted Richard Blackwood to notice me. I thought if I wore something connected to Eleanor Bennett, people would assume I came from a family that mattered.””

“You already mattered,” I said quietly.

“You just didn't believe it.””

She looked at me, tears gathering in her eyes.

Then she placed the pearls in my hand.

“I don't expect you to forgive me.””

“I don't.””

She nodded.

“But I believe you didn't put that photograph here.””

Madison looked toward the door.

“Then who did?””

A sound came from downstairs.

The front door opening.

Then footsteps.

My father returned carrying a manila folder. He looked even more exhausted than before.

“I found it.””

He placed the folder on the bed.

Inside was a photograph of a man standing outside a hotel. His face was turned slightly away from the camera, but the scar on his cheek was unmistakable.

Alexander Hayes.

Alive.

The date printed on the back was eleven years old.

I stared at the image.

“Who took this?””

“An investigator Eleanor hired.””

“Where is he now?””

Daniel shook his head.

“I don't know. He disappeared after he sent the photograph.””

Victoria leaned forward.

“What's the bank transfer?””

Daniel pulled out a photocopy.

It showed a payment of two hundred thousand dollars from a company associated with Alexander Hayes to a private account registered under the name Thomas Reed.

The transfer date was three days after Alexander's supposed death.

“Who is Thomas Reed?”” I asked.

Daniel looked at me.

“I don't know.””

Madison suddenly gasped.

“Wait.””

She reached for her phone and opened a photograph from the gala.

It showed a man standing near the ballroom entrance, dressed in a dark suit. His face was partially obscured by another guest.

But I could see the scar.

My hands went numb.

“That's him.””

Victoria grabbed the phone.

“Where did you take this?””

“During the gala. I was photographing the guests for my social media.””

Daniel stared at the screen.

“Impossible.””

I looked at him.

“You said you saw him after the funeral.””

He nodded.

“Not in person. I received the letter.””

“But you didn't know whether he was alive.””

“No.””

I turned toward Victoria.

“Did you recognize him at the gala?””

She shook her head.

“I wasn't looking for him.””

Madison enlarged the image.

The man was standing near the service corridor, watching the stage.

Watching me.

I felt a chill spread through my body.

“He was there when Richard called me onto the stage.””

Daniel's expression changed.

“He knew you were coming.””

I looked at the photograph again.

Then I noticed something else.

The man was holding a folded piece of paper.

On it was a handwritten name.

*Olivia.*

My phone rang.

An unknown number.

I stared at the screen.

No one moved.

Then I answered.

“Hello?””

A man's voice came through the speaker.

“Olivia Bennett?””

I couldn't speak.

“I see you've found the photograph.””

My knees weakened.

“Who is this?””

A quiet laugh.

“You already know.””

I gripped the phone.

“Alexander?””

A pause.

Then the voice said, “Your mother used to call me Alex.””

My father covered his mouth.

Victoria began to cry.

I forced myself to speak.

“Are you alive?””

“Very much so.””

“Why did you pretend to be dead?””

“Because it was the only way I could keep certain people from finding me.””

“Who?””

He laughed softly.

“That's the question your mother spent the last months of her life trying to answer.””

I felt sick.

“What do you want from me?””

“To give you something your mother promised me.””

“What?””

“The truth.””

I looked at the photograph on the bed.

“Then tell me.””

His voice grew serious.

“Not over the phone. Meet me tomorrow morning at the old St. Agnes building. Come alone.””

“No.””

“Then you'll never know why Eleanor chose Daniel over me.””

I swallowed.

“Why did she?””

“Because she believed I had betrayed her.””

“Did you?””

Silence.

Then he said, “I betrayed her once. But not in the way she believed.””

I closed my eyes.

“Why should I trust you?””

“You shouldn't.””

The answer startled me.

“Trust no one, Olivia. Not Daniel. Not Richard.

Not Victoria. And certainly not me.””

“Then why should I meet you?””

“Because I have the original donor consent form. And because it contains a name that will explain everything.””

“What name?””

He paused.

Then he said, “The name of the person who changed your mother's records.””

The line went dead.

I lowered the phone.

For several seconds, I couldn't move.

Then I looked at my father.

He was staring at me with an expression I had never seen before.

Not fear.

Not shame.

Recognition.

“You know who changed the records,” I whispered.

Daniel closed his eyes.

“Yes.””

My throat tightened.

“Who?””

He opened his mouth.

Before he could answer, a sharp crash came from downstairs.

Glass shattered.

Someone screamed.

We rushed toward the staircase.

At the bottom, the front door stood open.

A vase lay broken across the floor.

And on the hallway wall, written in thick black paint, were the words:

*STOP LOOKING FOR THE DEAD.*

Beneath them was a second sentence.

*OR THE NEXT FUNERAL WILL BE YOURS.*

Madison began sobbing.

Victoria pulled her daughter into her arms.

My father reached for his phone.

I stood frozen on the stairs, staring at the threat.

Then I noticed something on the floor beside the broken vase.

A small white envelope.

My name was written across it.

I picked it up.

Inside was a single sheet of paper.

Olivia,

If you want to know who changed the records, ask Richard what happened the night he and Eleanor ended their engagement.

He has told you he walked away because he respected her choice.

Ask him why he was standing outside the clinic when your mother was taken to the hospital.

I read the message twice.

Then I looked at my phone.

Richard had called me three times while we were upstairs.

I called him back.

He answered immediately.

“Olivia? Thank God. Are you safe?””

“Richard, I need you to tell me the truth.””

“About what?””

I stared at the message.

“Were you at St. Agnes the night my mother was taken to the hospital?””

Silence.

A long, terrible silence.

Then Richard said, “Yes.””

My chest tightened.

“Why?””

His voice broke.

“Because Eleanor had called me for help.””

“Help with what?””

He took a breath.

“She had discovered who had changed your donor records.””

I gripped the phone.

“Who was it?””

Richard whispered a name.

And when I heard it, I understood why my father had been so terrified of the truth.

Because the person who had altered my mother's medical records was not Alexander Hayes.

It was not Daniel Bennett.

It was not Victoria.

It was someone who had spent eleven years standing beside me, telling me that everything would be all right.

Someone I had trusted with my life.

May you like

Someone whose name was written on the original consent form.

*Margaret Ellis.*

Related Stories

Other posts