Chapter 5: The Complaints That Disappeared

Margaret read the message twice.
Then she looked toward Arthur.
“Sir, I think we should move this discussion to the conference room.””
Arthur shook his head.
“Not yet. What does the message say?””
Margaret hesitated.
“It says that several guest complaints were removed from the hotel's internal dashboard before the monthly regional review.””
Vanessa immediately stepped forward.
“That is a serious accusation.””
Margaret looked at her.
“I haven't accused anyone.””
“You're standing here reading a message about deleted complaints while looking directly at me.””
“Because you're the general manager.””
Vanessa's face tightened.
“I had nothing to do with deleting guest complaints.””
Arthur watched her carefully.
“Then this should be easy to investigate.””
Margaret unlocked her phone.
“I've asked the finance controller to come downstairs.””
“Who is that?”” Arthur asked.
“Thomas Reed. He's been with the company for eleven years.””
Vanessa looked uncomfortable.
“Thomas doesn't understand the guest management system.””
Margaret raised her eyes.
“He understands financial reporting.””
“That's not the same thing.””
“No,” Margaret replied.
“But it doesn't mean his information should be dismissed.””
Arthur glanced at Daniel.
“Would you mind staying a little longer?””
Daniel nodded.
“Of course, sir.””
Vanessa gave an incredulous laugh.
“Why is he still here? He's been fired.””
Arthur turned toward her.
“I remember.””
“Then perhaps he should leave.””
“Perhaps. But I haven't finished speaking with him.””
Daniel remained silent.
Arthur looked at him.
“Do you know anything about the complaint system?””
Daniel hesitated.
“A little.””
“What do you mean?””
Daniel glanced toward the reception computer.
“Some complaints came through the guest feedback portal. Others were entered manually after someone spoke to the front desk.””
Margaret nodded.
“That's correct.””
Daniel continued.
“When a guest complained about something serious, we were supposed to create a case number and forward it to management.””
“Did you do that?”” Arthur asked.
“Yes.””
“Were those complaints always acknowledged?””
Daniel looked down.
“Not always.””
Vanessa interrupted.
“Because some complaints were duplicates or didn't require formal investigation.””
Daniel turned toward her.
“Some were, yes. But I remember several that never received a response.””
“Such as?””
Daniel looked at her.
“The woman whose mother was told the hotel wasn't a nursing home.””
Vanessa's face hardened.
“You need to be careful about what you say.””
Daniel nodded.
“I am.””
Arthur placed a hand on the counter.
“Continue.””
Daniel took a breath.
“There was also a family from Ohio. Their reservation had been changed without their knowledge. They arrived with two children and were told the room type they booked wasn't available.””
Margaret looked up.
“I remember that case.””
Daniel nodded.
“The father asked whether the hotel could arrange another room. Ms. Cole told him that if he wanted special treatment, he should book a more expensive property.””
Vanessa snapped.
“That is not what happened.””
Daniel didn't raise his voice.
“I was standing there.””
Arthur looked toward Margaret.
“Do we have a record?””
Margaret checked her phone.
“I'll search the case number.””
Before she could continue, the elevator doors opened.
A man in his fifties hurried into the lobby.
He wore a light-blue shirt with his tie loosened and carried a black laptop bag.
Thomas Reed.
“Margaret?””
She raised her hand.
“Thomas. Thank you for coming down.””
Thomas looked at Arthur.
His expression immediately changed.
“Mr. Whitmore.””
Arthur extended his hand.
“Good afternoon, Thomas.””
“It's an honor to see you again, sir.””
“Thank you. I understand you sent Margaret some information.””
Thomas glanced at Vanessa.
“Is this about the guest complaint records?””
“Yes,” Margaret answered.
Thomas swallowed.
“I should probably explain this somewhere private.””
Arthur looked toward the lobby.
“Why?””
Thomas shifted his bag.
“Because the records involve several departments.””
“Then explain them carefully.””
Vanessa stepped forward.
“Thomas, before you say anything, I want to remind you that confidential operational information cannot be shared without authorization.””
Thomas looked uncomfortable.
“I'm aware of company policy.””
“Then you should also understand that incomplete information can cause unnecessary damage.””
Arthur interrupted.
“Mr. Reed, you can speak freely. I am asking you to explain what you found.””
Thomas nodded.
He opened his laptop bag and removed a thin folder.
“I began reviewing the complaint reconciliation reports three weeks ago. The numbers didn't match.””
Margaret leaned closer.
“Which numbers?””
“The guest feedback portal showed eighty-six complaints for the previous quarter. The monthly management report showed only fifty-two.””
Vanessa folded her arms.
“Because the portal counts duplicate submissions.””
Thomas nodded.
“That was my first assumption.””
He opened the folder.
“But after checking the individual case numbers, I found that twenty-seven complaints had been closed without a documented resolution.””
Margaret looked at him.
“Twenty-seven?””
“Yes.””
“And the remaining seven?””
“Some were duplicates. Others had been transferred to the appropriate departments.””
Arthur leaned forward.
“What happened to the twenty-seven?””
Thomas turned a page.
“Most were categorized as administrative errors, even when the guest descriptions involved staff conduct.””
Vanessa shook her head.
“That category was approved by management.””
Thomas looked at her.
“I know.””
“Then why are you presenting it as suspicious?””
“Because the original complaints were still accessible in the archived system, but the monthly reports had been changed.””
Margaret frowned.
“Changed by whom?””
Thomas hesitated.
“I don't have the authorization records yet.””
Vanessa gave a short laugh.
“Then you don't have evidence.””
Thomas looked down at the folder.
“I have evidence that the records don't match.””
Arthur nodded.
“That's enough to investigate.””
Vanessa stepped toward Thomas.
“You've been working in this hotel for eleven years. You know how much pressure we face. Do you really want to turn a reporting adjustment into a scandal?””
Thomas looked at her.
“It's not an adjustment if it changes the meaning of the report.””
The words were quiet.
But they struck harder than a raised voice.
Arthur studied him.
“Did you report this before today?””
“Yes, sir.””
“To whom?””
“First, the hotel controller. Then to Ms. Cole's office.””
Vanessa's expression hardened.
“I don't recall receiving a formal report.””
Thomas opened another document.
“I sent an email.””
He turned the laptop toward Margaret.
The subject line read:
*DISCREPANCY IN GUEST COMPLAINT REPORTING — ACTION REQUIRED*
The date was six weeks earlier.
Margaret read the message.
Then she looked at Vanessa.
“Did you receive this?””
Vanessa stared at the screen.
“I receive hundreds of emails.””
“Did you respond?””
“I don't remember.””
Thomas scrolled down.
“There was a reply.””
Margaret read it aloud.
“'Please adjust the classifications before the regional report is submitted. We cannot continue presenting operational noise as a performance issue.''”
The lobby went completely silent.
Vanessa's eyes narrowed.
“That email has been taken out of context.””
Thomas spoke quietly.
“It's the full email.””
Arthur looked at him.
“Who wrote that response?””
Thomas didn't answer immediately.
He glanced toward Vanessa.
Then he pointed to the sender's name.
*Vanessa Cole — General Manager.*
Daniel looked at the screen.
His mouth fell open.
Vanessa quickly stepped forward.
“That doesn't prove anything. I was asking for accurate classification. That's part of my job.””
Arthur nodded.
“Then explain the classification.””
Vanessa took a breath.
“Some complaints were exaggerated. Some were based on misunderstandings. If we reported every minor inconvenience as a management failure, our performance numbers would become meaningless.””
Arthur listened.
“That's reasonable in principle.””
Vanessa appeared relieved.
“Exactly.””
“But did you instruct anyone to remove complaints from the report?””
“No.””
Thomas looked at the laptop.
“Not remove. Reclassify.””
Vanessa turned toward him.
“Thomas, stop.””
He closed his mouth.
Arthur noticed.
“Mr. Reed, continue.””
Thomas opened another document.
“This is the second message I found.””
He read the first line.
“'Please ensure the outstanding cases are closed before the regional audit. We need the property to remain on track for the annual leadership review.''”
Margaret looked up.
“When was that sent?””
“Two months ago.””
“By whom?””
Thomas pointed to the screen.
Again, Vanessa's name appeared.
Vanessa's expression changed.
“That was a routine reminder.””
Arthur asked, “Did the complaints receive actual resolutions?””
Thomas shook his head.
“Some did. Others were simply marked complete.””
Margaret slowly closed the folder.
“Vanessa, did you know that?””
“I assumed the department had followed the required process.””
Thomas looked at her.
“You approved the closures.””
Vanessa snapped.
“I approved the monthly report!””
“Which contained the closures.””
“That's not the same thing.””
Thomas lowered his eyes.
Arthur watched the exchange.
Then he turned toward Margaret.
“Is there a way to determine who changed the records?””
“Yes. The system keeps an audit trail.””
“Then obtain it.””
Margaret nodded.
“I'll contact the technology department.””
“Today.””
“Understood.””
Vanessa's voice became strained.
“Mr. Whitmore, I want to make something very clear. I have never deliberately harmed this company.””
Arthur looked at her.
“I hope that's true.””
“I've worked extremely hard to get where I am.””
“I don't doubt that.””
“I have sacrificed weekends, holidays, and personal time. I've taken difficult decisions that nobody else wanted to make.””
Arthur nodded.
“Leadership does involve sacrifice.””
Vanessa's eyes filled slightly.
“Then why are you treating me like a criminal?””
Arthur's expression softened, but his answer did not.
“I'm treating you like a manager whose decisions need to be examined.””
He glanced toward Daniel's badge.
“And the first decision we examined today was the decision to fire an employee for defending a guest.””
Vanessa looked away.
At that moment, Thomas's phone vibrated.
He checked it.
Then his eyebrows rose.
“Margaret?””
“What is it?””
“I just received something from the technology department.””
“Already?””
“They sent me a preliminary access log.””
Arthur leaned closer.
“What does it show?””
Thomas turned the phone around.
A list of user accounts appeared.
Margaret scanned the names.
Then she stopped.
“That's not possible.””
Vanessa stared at her.
“What?””
Margaret looked toward Arthur.
“Mr. Whitmore, the account that approved the largest number of complaint closures wasn't Vanessa's.””
Arthur frowned.
“Whose was it?””
Margaret looked at the screen again.
Then she read the name.
“Richard Hale.””
Vanessa's expression changed instantly.
Richard Hale was the hotel's director of sales.
He had worked closely with Vanessa for almost two years.
And according to the preliminary audit log, his account had been used to approve thirty-one complaint closures.
Thomas scrolled further.
“There is something else.””
“What?”” Margaret asked.
“The account activity began before the first complaint was even submitted.””
Arthur's eyes narrowed.
“How is that possible?””
Thomas looked at the timestamp.
Then he looked at Vanessa.
“Because the account was being used to close complaints that hadn't been filed yet.””
Vanessa took a step backward.
For the first time, she looked genuinely frightened.
May you like
And Arthur understood that someone might have been manipulating more than the hotel's reputation.
Someone might have been preparing the records long before the complaints arrived.