wink

Chapter 2: The Manager's Version of the Truth

Nicole had worked at Walsh House for nearly three years.

She knew how to speak to wealthy customers, how to calm angry guests, and how to make problems disappear before they reached the owner.

Most importantly, she knew how to control a room.

Or at least, she thought she did.

When Gavin Walsh walked toward her, she immediately changed her expression.

Her shoulders relaxed.

Her voice softened.

She even took a small step backward, creating the appearance of someone who had been frightened by an aggressive customer.

"Mr. Walsh, thank goodness you're here.""

Gavin didn't respond.

He stood beside his father, one hand resting gently on Ben's back.

"What happened?""

Nicole glanced at Frank.

"He became confrontational after I asked him to follow our dining-room policies.""

Frank raised an eyebrow.

"Is that what we're calling it?""

Gavin looked at his father.

"Let her finish.""

Nicole nodded gratefully.

"Your father was speaking aggressively to one of my servers. I approached him to calm things down, but he became angry. He swung his arm toward me, knocked over his drink, and nearly hit me.""

She paused.

Then she added the detail she believed would settle everything.

"Eli witnessed the entire thing.""

Gavin turned toward the floor supervisor.

"Eli?""

Eli stood with his hands clasped in front of him.

"Yes, sir.""

"Did you see my father swing at Nicole?""

Eli swallowed.

Nicole stared at him.

It was the same look she had given him earlier.

The look that said his answer had already been decided.

Eli glanced at Frank.

Then at Gavin.

"Mr. Walsh, I—"

Nicole interrupted.

"I understand this is upsetting because he's your father, but I have to enforce the same standards with everyone. We can't allow customers to assault staff.""

Gavin's expression remained controlled.

"Nobody has said you shouldn't enforce standards.""

"Exactly. And I was only trying to protect my employees.""

Frank finally spoke.

"By slapping a seventy-two-year-old man holding a baby?""

Nicole's face flushed.

"You were shouting at me.""

"No, I wasn't.""

"You were being disrespectful.""

"That's not a reason to hit someone.""

Nicole turned toward Gavin.

"Sir, with respect, I don't think he should be allowed to turn this into a personal attack against me.""

Gavin looked at her for several seconds.

Then he asked a question that seemed to catch her off guard.

"Nicole, why was my father being asked to leave?""

She blinked.

"Because he was causing a disturbance.""

"Before or after you slapped him?""

Her lips parted.

"Mr. Walsh, I did not slap him.""

Frank reached into his pocket and removed a folded paper napkin.

There was a faint reddish stain on one corner.

He placed it on the table.

"Then perhaps you can explain the mark on my face.""

Gavin looked at it.

His eyes narrowed.

"Did you hit him?""

Nicole shook her head quickly.

"No.""

Frank gave a tired laugh.

"Unbelievable.""

Gavin raised one hand.

"Enough. I'm going to ask everyone the same questions, and I want honest answers.""

He turned to Marcus, the young waiter who had approached earlier.

"Marcus, were you here?""

Marcus looked startled.

"Yes, sir.""

"Tell me what you saw.""

Nicole immediately stepped forward.

"Marcus wasn't involved. He was working another section.""

Gavin didn't look at her.

"Marcus can answer for himself.""

The waiter swallowed.

"I came over after I heard the glass fall.""

"What did you see?""

"I saw Mr. Walsh holding the baby. His drink was spilled, and his cheek was red.""

"Did you see Nicole hit him?""

Marcus hesitated.

Nicole's eyes narrowed.

"Marcus.""

The young man looked down.

"I didn't see the actual slap, sir.""

Gavin nodded.

"Thank you. That's all I asked.""

He turned back to Eli.

"Now you.""

Eli's face had gone pale.

Nicole moved closer to him.

"He already told you. The customer was aggressive.""

Gavin slowly shook his head.

"I didn't ask you. I asked Eli.""

The room seemed to grow quieter.

Eli looked at his supervisor.

Then at Frank.

Frank didn't plead with him.

He didn't threaten him.

He simply waited.

Finally, Eli took a breath.

"That's exactly what Nicole made me say last time.""

Gavin stopped moving.

"What?""

Nicole's expression changed.

"Eli, be careful.""

Eli continued.

"She told me to say your father swung first. That's what she told me to say the last time something like this happened.""

Gavin's hand tightened around the back of his chair.

"Last time?""

Nicole laughed nervously.

"This is ridiculous. Eli is confused.""

"No, I'm not," Eli said.

His voice was shaking now, but he didn't stop.

"I know exactly what happened.""

Gavin stared at him.

"Was there another incident involving my father?""

Eli nodded.

"Yes, sir.""

Gavin looked toward Frank.

His father seemed just as surprised as he was.

"When?""

"Three weeks ago.""

Nicole immediately stepped forward.

"That has nothing to do with today.""

Gavin turned.

"Then why are you so worried about it?""

"Because you're allowing an employee to spread false accusations in front of customers!""

"You're the manager," Gavin replied.

"You should be the first person who wants the facts established.""

Nicole pressed her lips together.

For the first time, she seemed unable to find the right words.

Gavin looked at Eli again.

"What happened three weeks ago?""

Eli glanced at the dining room.

Several customers were still watching.

One older woman had put down her fork and was holding her phone in both hands.

Gavin noticed.

"Everyone can continue their meals. This conversation is not finished, but I won't ask customers to sit through a staff investigation.""

He turned to Nicole.

"Go to your office.""

"Mr. Walsh—"

"Now.""

Nicole stared at him.

Then she turned sharply and walked toward the back hallway.

Her heels struck the floor with angry little clicks.

Gavin waited until the office door closed.

Then he faced Eli.

"Start from the beginning.""

Eli looked as though he might collapse.

"Three weeks ago, an elderly woman came in for lunch. She had a reservation, but Nicole told the host to move her to the waiting area because a group of important clients had arrived.""

Gavin frowned.

"Why wasn't the reservation honored?""

"Nicole said the clients spent more money.""

"And?""

"The woman complained. She said she'd been waiting forty minutes and had already paid for parking.""

Frank listened carefully.

Eli continued.

"Nicole told her to stop making a scene. The woman asked for the manager's name. Nicole grabbed her handbag and dropped it on the floor.""

Gavin's face hardened.

"She did what?""

"Her medication and some papers fell out. The woman started crying. I helped her pick everything up.""

"Was there an argument?""

"Yes. Nicole said the woman was lying about her reservation.""

Gavin rubbed his forehead.

"Where does my father fit into this?""

Eli looked at Frank.

"Mr. Walsh was there.""

Frank slowly nodded.

"I remember.""

Gavin turned toward him.

"You never told me.""

"I didn't know it was serious enough to involve you.""

Eli continued.

"Your father asked Nicole to apologize. She refused. Then she told him to mind his own business.""

Frank remembered the moment.

The elderly woman had been wearing a pale green cardigan. Her hands had trembled as she gathered her medication from the floor.

He had helped her into a chair.

He had asked for a glass of water.

And when Nicole told him to leave the matter alone, he had quietly explained that humiliating an elderly customer was unacceptable.

But what happened afterward was something he hadn't expected.

Eli looked at Gavin.

"Nicole told me to write an incident report saying Mr. Walsh threatened her.""

Gavin's eyes widened.

"Did he?""

"No.""

"Then why did you write it?""

Eli lowered his head.

"She said she'd make sure I lost my job if I didn't.""

Gavin stared at him.

"And you agreed?""

Eli's eyes filled with tears.

"I have two kids, sir. I needed the job.""

Frank looked away.

He understood fear.

He also understood what fear could make people do.

Gavin pulled out a chair and sat down.

"Did anyone else witness that incident?""

Eli hesitated.

"Yes.""

"Who?""

Eli looked toward the kitchen.

"Someone who works here. Someone who saw Nicole do something much worse than drop that woman's handbag.""

Gavin leaned forward.

"What do you mean?""

Before Eli could answer, a voice came from behind them.

"I think you should hear what she told me to do with the security footage.""

May you like

It was Marcus.

And he was holding a small black flash drive.

Related Stories

Other posts