wink

Chapter 5: The Complaints Nobody Investigated

The first thing David did after ordering dinner was request the restaurant's guest complaint register.

Vanessa heard him ask Marcus for it.

Her stomach tightened.

She knew exactly where the register was kept.

For three years, she had made sure that complaints involving her management decisions never reached the corporate office.

Some were dismissed as misunderstandings.

Others were recorded as customer dissatisfaction.

A few had simply disappeared.

She had convinced herself that none of it mattered.

Until now.

"Marcus," David said, "please bring me the complaint register for the past twelve months.""

"Yes, sir.""

Vanessa stepped forward.

"Mr. Carter, the register contains confidential guest information.""

"I know.""

"Perhaps the operations director should review it.""

David looked at her.

"I am the owner.""

"Of course, sir. I only meant that the proper procedure—"

"The proper procedure is exactly what I'm asking for.""

Vanessa stopped talking.

Marcus disappeared into the office.

Helen sat quietly at the table while a waiter placed a small bowl of soup in front of her.

"Would you like some bread, Mrs. Carter?"" the waiter asked.

"That would be lovely. Thank you.""

The waiter smiled.

"Right away.""

David noticed how naturally the young man treated her.

He also noticed that Marcus had returned to his station with a different expression.

There was something Marcus wanted to say.

"Marcus," David called.

The waiter approached.

"Yes, sir?""

"Is there something else?""

Marcus glanced toward Vanessa.

"Sir, I think you should know that this isn't the first time Ms. Cole has treated a guest like that.""

Vanessa immediately turned.

"Marcus, don't.""

David looked at the young waiter.

"Please continue.""

Marcus took a breath.

"Three months ago, an older gentleman came in for lunch. He was wearing work clothes. He said he had come straight from a construction site because his wife had made a reservation for their anniversary.""

Helen stopped stirring her soup.

Marcus continued.

"Ms. Cole told him he couldn't sit in the main dining room because he looked dirty. She made him wait near the service entrance until his wife arrived.""

David's eyebrows drew together.

"Was there a reservation?""

"Yes, sir. Under his wife's name.""

"Did she arrive?""

"She did. She was very upset.""

Vanessa stepped forward.

"That situation was completely different.""

David looked at her.

"How?""

"The gentleman's clothing was inappropriate, and he had dirt on his shoes.""

Marcus shook his head.

"He had already offered to clean them, sir.""

Vanessa glared at him.

"That is not what happened.""

Marcus looked at David.

"The couple left before their food arrived.""

Helen lowered her spoon.

"That poor man.""

David turned toward Vanessa.

"Did you record that incident?""

Vanessa hesitated.

"I believe it was handled internally.""

"Meaning?""

"It was resolved.""

"By whom?""

"Me.""

David nodded slowly.

"And the complaint?""

Vanessa didn't answer.

Marcus returned with the register before she could respond.

David opened it on the table.

The pages contained handwritten notes, printed emails, and incident summaries.

He began reading.

One complaint described a mother who had been asked to leave because her children were too noisy, even though other families were seated nearby.

Another came from a couple celebrating their fortieth anniversary. The husband had apparently been told that their table was needed for more important guests.

A third complaint described a man who had been ignored for twenty minutes after arriving alone.

David turned the pages.

The same name appeared repeatedly.

Vanessa Cole.

He looked up.

"How many complaints have been filed against your management?""

Vanessa crossed her arms.

"Some guests complain about everything.""

"How many?""

"I don't have the exact number.""

David turned another page.

"Twenty-three in twelve months.""

Vanessa's face tightened.

"Most were resolved.""

"Where are the resolutions?""

"On file.""

"Then why aren't they here?""

Vanessa looked toward the management corridor.

"I'd have to check.""

David closed the register.

"Do that.""

A few minutes passed.

Marcus brought Helen another glass of water.

She thanked him.

David was still examining the documents when his phone rang.

The caller was Richard Bennett, the regional operations director.

David answered.

"Richard.""

"David, I just heard there's a serious incident downstairs.""

"That's correct.""

"Is your mother involved?""

"She's the person who was mistreated.""

There was a pause.

"David, I understand you're upset.""

"I'm not interested in discussing my feelings. I'm interested in understanding why the restaurant manager believes she can physically push a guest out of the dining room.""

Richard exhaled.

"Let me come down. We can handle this privately.""

David looked toward Vanessa.

"Why privately?""

"To avoid unnecessary embarrassment.""

David's expression hardened.

"The embarrassment belongs to the person responsible.""

Richard lowered his voice.

"David, please. The hotel has an important corporate dinner next week. We don't need this becoming a public incident.""

David looked around at the diners.

"It already happened in public.""

He ended the call.

Vanessa looked relieved that someone from corporate management was getting involved.

"Mr. Carter, Richard knows how the restaurant operates. He can explain some of the operational pressures I've been dealing with.""

David didn't respond.

Instead, he turned toward Marcus.

"Did anyone ever instruct you not to record complaints?""

Marcus looked uncomfortable.

"Sir?""

"Did someone tell you to keep certain incidents out of the official system?""

Marcus glanced toward Vanessa.

She shook her head slightly.

David noticed.

"Marcus, I need an honest answer.""

The young waiter swallowed.

"Yes, sir.""

Vanessa's eyes widened.

"Marcus, be careful.""

David stood.

"Who told you?""

Marcus looked down.

"Ms. Cole.""

The manager stepped forward.

"That is absolutely false.""

Marcus continued.

"Last month, a guest sent an email about being refused service. Ms. Cole told me to write that the guest had voluntarily left because he couldn't afford the menu.""

Vanessa's voice rose.

"He was shouting at the staff!""

"He wasn't, ma'am.""

"Don't call me ma'am!""

David looked between them.

"Why did you write that?""

Marcus hesitated.

"Because I was afraid of losing my job.""

The answer changed something in David's expression.

He looked at the young man for several seconds.

Then he said quietly, "You shouldn't have been put in that position.""

Marcus lowered his eyes.

"I'm sorry, sir.""

"Don't apologize for telling the truth.""

Vanessa shook her head.

"This is ridiculous. Marcus is a junior employee who doesn't understand the pressures of running a restaurant.""

David looked at her.

"Then perhaps you should explain those pressures.""

Vanessa opened her mouth.

But before she could answer, the restaurant doors opened.

A woman in a charcoal business suit entered carrying a leather portfolio.

Richard Bennett had arrived.

He walked straight toward David.

"David, we need to talk.""

"About what?""

Richard glanced toward Helen.

"First, I want to apologize to your mother.""

Helen gave him a polite nod.

"Thank you.""

Richard then lowered his voice.

"I've reviewed the situation briefly. Vanessa is a capable manager, and we shouldn't make a permanent decision based on one difficult evening.""

David stared at him.

"One difficult evening?""

Richard nodded.

"She has delivered strong revenue numbers.""

Helen quietly placed her spoon on the table.

David looked at Richard.

"Are you defending her?""

"I'm asking you to consider the bigger picture.""

"What bigger picture?""

Richard glanced toward the guests.

"The financial performance of the restaurant. The staffing structure. The upcoming hotel partnership.""

David's eyes narrowed.

"Are you suggesting we ignore what happened because Vanessa makes money?""

Richard shook his head.

"Not at all.""

"Then why are you bringing up revenue?""

Richard opened his portfolio.

"I've brought the quarterly performance reports. Vanessa's restaurant has exceeded its targets for eight consecutive quarters.""

David glanced at the documents.

Then he noticed something.

The reports contained a section labeled guest retention.

The numbers looked unusually high.

"Where did these figures come from?"" he asked.

"From the restaurant's internal system.""

David looked toward Vanessa.

"Are these the same figures you submitted to corporate?""

Vanessa nodded.

"Yes, sir.""

David examined another page.

Then he noticed a line that didn't match the complaint register.

The report claimed that customer dissatisfaction had fallen by forty percent.

But the register contained dozens of complaints.

He looked at Richard.

"Did you independently verify these numbers?""

Richard paused.

"Vanessa's department submitted them.""

David closed the portfolio.

"So nobody checked?""

Richard looked uncomfortable.

"We have several layers of reporting.""

David looked toward Helen.

His mother was no longer eating.

She was watching Richard with quiet concern.

Then David looked at Vanessa.

"Tell me something. How many complaints did you remove from the official reporting system?""

Vanessa's face drained of color.

"None.""

David held her gaze.

"Are you certain?""

"Absolutely.""

He turned to Marcus.

"Please ask the IT department to preserve the restaurant's complaint database and its revision history.""

Marcus nodded.

Richard shifted uncomfortably.

"David, perhaps we should move this discussion upstairs.""

David didn't move.

"No. I think we should finish it here.""

Then a voice came from behind Richard.

"Mr. Carter, there's something you need to see.""

It was Olivia, David's executive assistant.

She held a tablet in both hands.

"I checked the security system," she said.

"The footage from tonight is available.""

David took the tablet.

Olivia hesitated.

"There's also footage from another evening. The date is three months ago.""

David looked up.

"Why?""

Olivia's expression was serious.

"Because the same manager appears to have done something very similar to another guest.""

May you like

Vanessa gripped the edge of the counter.

And this time, she didn't even try to smile.

Related Stories

Other posts