wink

Chapter 9: The Person Ryan Was Protecting

"His brother.""

Vanessa's voice shook.

"Ryan transferred part of the money toHis brother.""

Vanessa's voice shook.

"Ryan transferred part of the money to his brother, Michael.""

Ryan immediately turned his brother, Michael.""

Ryan immediately turned toward her.

"Don't bring Michael into this.""

Vanessa held her phone tighter.

"You told me he was helping you.""

toward her.

"Don't bring Michael into this.""

Vanessa held her phone tighter.

"You told me he was helping you.""

"He was.""

"He was.""

"You told me he was keeping the money safe.""

"He was.""

"Then"You told me he was keeping the money safe.""

"He was.""

"Then why did you tell me the account was untouchable?""

Ryan stepped toward her.

"Because you don't why did you tell me the account was untouchable?""

Ryan stepped toward her.

"Because you don't understand how business works.""

Vanessa laughed bitterly.

"Apparently, neither do I.""

Judge Harris looked toward Collins understand how business works.""

Vanessa laughed bitterly.

"Apparently, neither do I.""

Judge Harris looked toward Collins.

"Mr. Collins, I suggest you advise.

"Mr. Collins, I suggest you advise your client not to approach the witness.""

Collins moved quickly.

"Ryan, sit down.""

Ryan reluctantly returned your client not to approach the witness.""

Collins moved quickly.

"Ryan, sit down.""

Ryan reluctantly returned to his chair.

Judge Harris turned toward Vanessa.

"Ms. Vanessa, do you have evidence supporting this statement?""

"Yes, Your Honor.""

"Has to his chair.

Judge Harris turned toward Vanessa.

"Ms. Vanessa, do you have evidence supporting this statement?""

"Yes, Your Honor.""

"Has it been provided to your attorney?""

"Not yet. I can provide it.""

"Then it it been provided to your attorney?""

"Not yet. I can provide it.""

"Then it should be submitted through the proper process. The court will not rely should be submitted through the proper process. The court will not rely on an unsupported statement.""

Vanessa nodded.

Park stood.

"Your Honor, this information on an unsupported statement.""

Vanessa nodded.

Park stood.

"Your Honor, this information may be relevant to identifying the destination of the loan proceeds. We request permission to supplement may be relevant to identifying the destination of the loan proceeds. We request permission to supplement our financial submission once the records are obtained.""

"Granted.""

Ryan leaned back.

His expression was no longer our financial submission once the records are obtained.""

"Granted.""

Ryan leaned back.

His expression was no longer angry.

It was empty.

The hearing angry.

It was empty.

The hearing was approaching its end, but the revelations were not.

Judge Harris looked at Collins was approaching its end, but the revelations were not.

Judge Harris looked at Collins.

"Does your client have any explanation for the transfer to his brother?""

Collins spoke carefully.

"My.

"Does your client have any explanation for the transfer to his brother?""

Collins spoke carefully.

"My client maintains that the transactions were legitimate business arrangements. We will provide supporting documentation.""

Park asked client maintains that the transactions were legitimate business arrangements. We will provide supporting documentation.""

Park asked a question.

"Can you identify the business purpose today?""

Collins paused.

"Not without reviewing the records.""

" a question.

"Can you identify the business purpose today?""

Collins paused.

"Not without reviewing the records.""

"WasWas there a written contract?""

"I cannot confirm that.""

"An invoice?""

"I cannot confirm that either.""

Park nodded.

"Then we agree that the court should there a written contract?""

"I cannot confirm that.""

"An invoice?""

"I cannot confirm that either.""

Park nodded.

"Then we agree that the court should obtain the complete banking records.""

Collins sighed.

"We do.""

Judge Harris made obtain the complete banking records.""

Collins sighed.

"We do.""

Judge Harris made another note.

"Very well.""

I sat quietly.

The name Michael brought back memories.

Ryan another note.

"Very well.""

I sat quietly.

The name Michael brought back memories.

Ryan's younger brother had visited our house several times during the marriage. He was charming, always smiling, and constantly's younger brother had visited our house several times during the marriage. He was charming, always smiling, and constantly asking Ryan for financial help.

He had once borrowed five thousand dollars from me for a business opportunity.

I never asking Ryan for financial help.

He had once borrowed five thousand dollars from me for a business opportunity.

I never saw it again.

When I asked Ryan about repayment, he told me not saw it again.

When I asked Ryan about repayment, he told me not to embarrass his family.

I had let to embarrass his family.

I had let it go.

Now I wondered whether that had been the beginning of it go.

Now I wondered whether that had been the beginning of something much larger.

During a short pause, Park leaned toward me.

" something much larger.

During a short pause, Park leaned toward me.

"Do you know Michael?""

"Yes. He's Ryan's brother.""

"Did he have access to your property documents?""

IDo you know Michael?""

"Yes. He's Ryan's brother.""

"Did he have access to your property documents?""

I thought carefully.

"He visited our house. thought carefully.

"He visited our house. He knew where we kept important paperwork.""

" He knew where we kept important paperwork.""

"Did he ever handle your financial documents?""

"Once. Ryan asked him to help organize someDid he ever handle your financial documents?""

"Once. Ryan asked him to help organize some files while we were preparing for an files while we were preparing for an insurance review.""

Park wrote something down.

"When was that?""

"Late September.""

He stopped writing.

"That insurance review.""

Park wrote something down.

"When was that?""

"Late September.""

He stopped writing.

"That may be relevant.""

I looked at him.

"Are you saying Michael could have helped prepare the transfer?""

"I'm may be relevant.""

I looked at him.

"Are you saying Michael could have helped prepare the transfer?""

"I'm saying we should establish who had access to the information and when.""

I nodded.

Across the room, Ryan was speaking to saying we should establish who had access to the information and when.""

I nodded.

Across the room, Ryan was speaking to Collins again.

This time, his attorney looked genuinely furious.

I heard Collins say, "You told me Michael had Collins again.

This time, his attorney looked genuinely furious.

I heard Collins say, "You told me Michael had nothing to do with the property.""

Ryan answered quietly.

"He doesn't.""

"Then why is his nothing to do with the property.""

Ryan answered quietly.

"He doesn't.""

"Then why is his name appearing in the financial records?""

"Because I needed somewhere to put the money.""

Collins stared at him.

"That is not name appearing in the financial records?""

"Because I needed somewhere to put the money.""

Collins stared at him.

"That is not a legal explanation.""

Ryan lowered his voice further.

"He's my brother.""

Collins closed a legal explanation.""

Ryan lowered his voice further.

"He's my brother.""

Collins closed his folder.

"That does not make him invisible.""

Vanessa was watching them.

Her phone his folder.

"That does not make him invisible.""

Vanessa was watching them.

Her phone buzzed.

She looked at the screen and suddenly went pale.

Then she turned toward Park.

" buzzed.

She looked at the screen and suddenly went pale.

Then she turned toward Park.

"Mr. Park?""

He looked up.

"Yes?""

"I just received a message from Michael.""

Ryan stood soMr. Park?""

He looked up.

"Yes?""

"I just received a message from Michael.""

Ryan stood so quickly his chair scraped backward.

"Give me that phone.""

Vanessa stepped away.

"No.""

"Van quickly his chair scraped backward.

"Give me that phone.""

Vanessa stepped away.

"No.""

"Vanessa, give it to me.""

"Whyessa, give it to me.""

"Why?""

"Because you don't know what you're reading.""

She stared?""

"Because you don't know what you're reading.""

She stared at him.

"Then explain it.""

He reached toward her phone.

The bailiff moved between them.

" at him.

"Then explain it.""

He reached toward her phone.

The bailiff moved between them.

"Mr. Ryan, step back.""

Vanessa looked at the screen again.

Then she read the message aloud.

"'Mr. Ryan, step back.""

Vanessa looked at the screen again.

Then she read the message aloud.

"'Tell Ryan I can't keep covering for him. If the lender asksTell Ryan I can't keep covering for him. If the lender asks about the authorization, I'm not taking responsibility.''"

Nobody moved.

Park extended about the authorization, I'm not taking responsibility.''"

Nobody moved.

Park extended his hand.

"Ms. Vanessa, may I see the message?""

She looked at her attorney, who had just entered his hand.

"Ms. Vanessa, may I see the message?""

She looked at her attorney, who had just entered the courtroom after being contacted during the recess.

He approached her and spoke quietly.

"Don't hand over your phone without the courtroom after being contacted during the recess.

He approached her and spoke quietly.

"Don't hand over your phone without first discussing the appropriate procedure.""

Vanessa nodded.

Judge Harris looked at Ryan.

first discussing the appropriate procedure.""

Vanessa nodded.

Judge Harris looked at Ryan.

"Mr. Ryan, is Michael involved in preparing the property documents?""

Ryan shook his head.

"No.""

Park asked, "Then why is he"Mr. Ryan, is Michael involved in preparing the property documents?""

Ryan shook his head.

"No.""

Park asked, "Then why is he telling Ms. Vanessa that he cannot keep covering for you?""

"He's being dramatic.""

"About what?""

"Family problems.""

Judge Harris leaned telling Ms. Vanessa that he cannot keep covering for you?""

"He's being dramatic.""

"About what?""

"Family problems.""

Judge Harris leaned forward.

"Mr. Ryan, this court is examining a disputed property transfer and an apparently forward.

"Mr. Ryan, this court is examining a disputed property transfer and an apparently unauthorized loan. I am not interested in unrelated family disagreements.""

Ryan nodded.

"Understood.""

But his hands were trembling.

Van unauthorized loan. I am not interested in unrelated family disagreements.""

Ryan nodded.

"Understood.""

But his hands were trembling.

Vanessa looked at him with something close to disgust.

"You said Michael was going to handle everything.""

Ryanessa looked at him with something close to disgust.

"You said Michael was going to handle everything.""

Ryan didn't respond.

"You said he knew people at the lender.""

"Stop didn't respond.

"You said he knew people at the lender.""

"Stop.""

"You said he could make the paperwork go through.""

"Vanessa!""

She flinched.

Then she looked at Judge.""

"You said he could make the paperwork go through.""

"Vanessa!""

She flinched.

Then she looked at Judge Harris.

"Your Honor, I think Michael may have signed something, too.""

Collins immediately stood.

"Your Honor, Harris.

"Your Honor, I think Michael may have signed something, too.""

Collins immediately stood.

"Your Honor, we object to speculation.""

Judge Harris nodded.

"That is fair. Ms. Vanessa, do we object to speculation.""

Judge Harris nodded.

"That is fair. Ms. Vanessa, do you have a document or communication supporting that statement?""

She searched her phone.

"Yes.""

She found an image.

It you have a document or communication supporting that statement?""

She searched her phone.

"Yes.""

She found an image.

It showed a scanned document with a signature near the bottom.

Vanessa stared at it for a moment.

Then she handed the phone to her attorney.

He showed a scanned document with a signature near the bottom.

Vanessa stared at it for a moment.

Then she handed the phone to her attorney.

He examined it.

His expression changed.

He whispered something to her.

She nodded.

Park watched examined it.

His expression changed.

He whispered something to her.

She nodded.

Park watched them carefully.

"Is that the alleged authorization?""

Vanessa shook her head.

"No. It's a separate document them carefully.

"Is that the alleged authorization?""

Vanessa shook her head.

"No. It's a separate document.""

"What does it say?""

She looked toward Ryan.

"It's an acknowledgment that someone.""

"What does it say?""

She looked toward Ryan.

"It's an acknowledgment that someone had verified the owner's consent.""

Park became still.

Judge Harris looked up.

"Who signed had verified the owner's consent.""

Park became still.

Judge Harris looked up.

"Who signed it?""

Vanessa hesitated.

Then she answered.

"Michael Ryan.""

Ryan stood.

"That's it?""

Vanessa hesitated.

Then she answered.

"Michael Ryan.""

Ryan stood.

"That's not what it looks like!""

Judge Harris raised his voice.

"Sit down immediately.""

Ryan obeyed.

not what it looks like!""

Judge Harris raised his voice.

"Sit down immediately.""

Ryan obeyed.

Park turned toward me.

"Elena, do you know Michael's signature?""

"Yes.""

Park turned toward me.

"Elena, do you know Michael's signature?""

"Yes.""

"Would you recognize it?""

"I believe so.""

Park nodded.

Judge Harris addressed the attorneys.

"This"Would you recognize it?""

"I believe so.""

Park nodded.

Judge Harris addressed the attorneys.

"This document has not yet been authenticated. It will be submitted for proper examination, along with the original document has not yet been authenticated. It will be submitted for proper examination, along with the original loan file and any supporting records.""

Collins stood.

"Your Honor, we request that the court make clear that no loan file and any supporting records.""

Collins stood.

"Your Honor, we request that the court make clear that no finding has been made against Mr. Michael Ryan, who is not a finding has been made against Mr. Michael Ryan, who is not a party to this divorce proceeding.""

"That is correct," Judge Harris replied.

"The court is making no finding against an party to this divorce proceeding.""

"That is correct," Judge Harris replied.

"The court is making no finding against an individual who is not before it.""

He paused.

"However, the document raises questions that must individual who is not before it.""

He paused.

"However, the document raises questions that must be addressed through the appropriate legal process.""

Ryan looked at Vanessa be addressed through the appropriate legal process.""

Ryan looked at Vanessa.

His voice was low.

"You promised me you wouldn't involve my family.""

She stared back.

"You involved my family when you.

His voice was low.

"You promised me you wouldn't involve my family.""

She stared back.

"You involved my family when you used my account.""

"That money was for us.""

"Then why did your used my account.""

"That money was for us.""

"Then why did your brother get it?""

Ryan looked away.

The judge began reviewing the proposed temporary orders.

I thought brother get it?""

Ryan looked away.

The judge began reviewing the proposed temporary orders.

I thought the hearing was finally ending.

Then Park reached into his briefcase one more time.

"Your Honor, may the hearing was finally ending.

Then Park reached into his briefcase one more time.

"Your Honor, may I clarify one issue regarding the property title?""

Judge Harris looked up.

"Go I clarify one issue regarding the property title?""

Judge Harris looked up.

"Go ahead.""

Park placed a certified copy of the original purchase record on the bench.

"This confirms that Ms. Elena purchased the property using ahead.""

Park placed a certified copy of the original purchase record on the bench.

"This confirms that Ms. Elena purchased the property using funds from the sale of her previous residence. The down payment and initial mortgage payments originated funds from the sale of her previous residence. The down payment and initial mortgage payments originated from her separate account.""

Judge Harris examined it.

"Is this the original purchase record?""

"Yes, Your Honor. from her separate account.""

Judge Harris examined it.

"Is this the original purchase record?""

"Yes, Your Honor. Certified by the county property office.""

Park placed another page beside it.

"And this is the mortgage payment Certified by the county property office.""

Park placed another page beside it.

"And this is the mortgage payment history.""

The judge studied the two documents.

Ryan's attorney looked down.

Park continued.

"The disputed loan was not history.""

The judge studied the two documents.

Ryan's attorney looked down.

Park continued.

"The disputed loan was not used to acquire the residence. It was obtained years used to acquire the residence. It was obtained years after Ms. Elena had already purchased it.""

Ryan mut after Ms. Elena had already purchased it.""

Ryan muttered, "We were married.""

Judge Harris looked at him.

"That fact does not change the date of purchase.""

Then thetered, "We were married.""

Judge Harris looked at him.

"That fact does not change the date of purchase.""

Then the judge turned toward me.

"Ms. Elena, do you intend to seek exclusive confirmation of judge turned toward me.

"Ms. Elena, do you intend to seek exclusive confirmation of ownership as ownership as part of the divorce proceedings?""

I stood.

"Yes, Your Honor.""

"Do you intend to pursue the disputed transfer and loan through the appropriate legal channels?""

"Yes.""

"Very part of the divorce proceedings?""

I stood.

"Yes, Your Honor.""

"Do you intend to pursue the disputed transfer and loan through the appropriate legal channels?""

"Yes.""

"Very well.""

He reviewed his notes.

"The temporary restrictions will remain in place. The property shall not be transferred well.""

He reviewed his notes.

"The temporary restrictions will remain in place. The property shall not be transferred or encumbered. The parties must preserve all relevant documents and electronic communications or encumbered.

The parties must preserve all relevant documents and electronic communications. The court will set a further date after the requested records have been produced.""

Ryan lowered his head.

Then. The court will set a further date after the requested records have been produced.""

Ryan lowered his head.

Then Judge Harris added something unexpected.

"Given the evidence presented, the disputed transfer will also Judge Harris added something unexpected.

"Given the evidence presented, the disputed transfer will also be referred for review by the appropriate authorities. This is not a finding of criminal liability, but the circumstances warrant examination.""

be referred for review by the appropriate authorities. This is not a finding of criminal liability, but the circumstances warrant examination.""

Vanessa closed her eyes.

Collins whispered to Ryan.

Ryan didn't respond.

The judge adjVanessa closed her eyes.

Collins whispered to Ryan.

Ryan didn't respond.

The judge adjourned the hearing.

Everyone began gathering their belongings.

I reached for my handbag.

Park collected the documents and placedourned the hearing.

Everyone began gathering their belongings.

I reached for my handbag.

Park collected the documents and placed them inside his briefcase.

"How are you feeling?"" he asked.

I considered the question.

"Exhaust them inside his briefcase.

"How are you feeling?"" he asked.

I considered the question.

"Exhausted.""

"That's understandable.""

I glanced toward Ryan.

He was standing alone.

Vanessa had moved several feet away from himed.""

"That's understandable.""

I glanced toward Ryan.

He was standing alone.

Vanessa had moved several feet away from him.

Their relationship, once displayed so.

Their relationship, once displayed so proudly in front of me, now seemed to exist only in the space between two people who were afraid proudly in front of me, now seemed to exist only in the space between two people who were afraid of what the other might reveal.

Ryan approached our table.

"Elena.""

Park stepped forward.

"Mr of what the other might reveal.

Ryan approached our table.

"Elena.""

Park stepped forward.

"Mr. Ryan, please communicate through counsel.""

"I just want one minute.""

I looked at him.

"Say. Ryan, please communicate through counsel.""

"I just want one minute.""

I looked at him.

"Say what you need to say.""

He glanced around the courtroom.

Then he lowered his voice.

"I never thought it would get this far what you need to say.""

He glanced around the courtroom.

Then he lowered his voice.

"I never thought it would get this far.""

I stared at him.

"You thought I would never.""

I stared at him.

"You thought I would never find out.""

He shook his head.

"I was under pressure.""

"So was I. find out.""

He shook his head.

"I was under pressure.""

"So was I. I just didn't use your house as collateral.""

He looked down.

"I made mistakes.""

"Ele I just didn't use your house as collateral.""

He looked down.

"I made mistakes.""

"Eleven years of marriage is not a mistake, Ryan. But what you did with it was your choice.""

His eyes filled slightlyven years of marriage is not a mistake, Ryan. But what you did with it was your choice.""

His eyes filled slightly.

"Can we talk about reconciliation?""

I almost didn't recognize the word.

".

"Can we talk about reconciliation?""

I almost didn't recognize the word.

"Reconciliation?""

"Maybe we can work something out.""

I looked at him for a long moment.

"Do you want yourReconciliation?""

"Maybe we can work something out.""

I looked at him for a long moment.

"Do you want your wife back, or do you want the house back?""

He didn't answer.

That was answer enough.

I walked toward wife back, or do you want the house back?""

He didn't answer.

That was answer enough.

I walked toward the courtroom doors.

Behind me, Vanessa called out.

"Elena!""

I stopped.

She approached slowly the courtroom doors.

Behind me, Vanessa called out.

"Elena!""

I stopped.

She approached slowly.

"I know I have no right to ask you for anything.""

I waited.

"But there's something I need to.

"I know I have no right to ask you for anything.""

I waited.

"But there's something I need to tell you.""

She glanced toward Ryan.

"Michael didn't just sign that acknowledgment.""

My tell you.""

She glanced toward Ryan.

"Michael didn't just sign that acknowledgment.""

My stomach tightened.

"What else did he do?""

Vanessa lowered her voice.

"He sent me stomach tightened.

"What else did he do?""

Vanessa lowered her voice.

"He sent me a copy of the original authorization.""

Park turned immediately a copy of the original authorization.""

Park turned immediately.

"Where is it?""

"In my email.""

"Have you opened it?""

"Yes.""

"What does it show?""

Vanessa swallowed.

Then she looked directly at me.

"It.

"Where is it?""

"In my email.""

"Have you opened it?""

"Yes.""

"What does it show?""

Vanessa swallowed.

Then she looked directly at me.

"It shows that the signature they used wasn't yours.""

I nodded slowly.

"I already shows that the signature they used wasn't yours.""

I nodded slowly.

"I already knew that.""

Vanessa shook her head.

"No, Elena. You don't understand.""

She took a breath.

"The knew that.""

Vanessa shook her head.

"No, Elena. You don't understand.""

She took a breath.

"The signature wasn't just copied. Someone traced it signature wasn't just copied. Someone traced it from a document that had been in your house.""

I felt a chill move down my spine.

from a document that had been in your house.""

I felt a chill move down my spine.

"Which document?""

Vanessa opened her email.

Then she showed the"Which document?""

Vanessa opened her email.

Then she showed the screen to Park.

He examined it.

His face changed.

"What is it?"" I asked.

He didn't screen to Park.

He examined it.

His face changed.

"What is it?"" I asked.

He didn't answer immediately.

He enlarged the attached image.

Then he turned the phone toward me.

answer immediately.

He enlarged the attached image.

Then he turned the phone toward me.

I recognized the paper.

It was an old document I had signed years earlier.

A document that had nothing to do with the house.

AI recognized the paper.

It was an old document I had signed years earlier.

A document that had nothing to do with the house.

A document I had kept in a locked drawer.

And the person who had access to that drawer was not Ryan.

It document I had kept in a locked drawer.

And the person who had access to that drawer was not Ryan.

It was someone I had trusted enough to give a spare key to.

Someone who had sat was someone I had trusted enough to give a spare key to.

Someone who had sat at my kitchen table.

Someone who had called me family.

Michael.

at my kitchen table.

Someone who had called me family.

Michael.

Park looked at me.

"Elena, IPark looked at me.

"Elena, I think we need to find out exactly how he obtained this document.""

And before I could answer, my phone began think we need to find out exactly how he obtained this document.""

And before I could answer, my phone began ringing.

The caller ID showed a name I hadn't seen in months.

*Michael Ryan.*

ringing.

May you like

The caller ID showed a name I hadn't seen in months.

*Michael Ryan.*

Related Stories

Other posts