wink

Chapter 8: The Money She Thought Was a Gift

"That's impossible.""

Vanessa's voice was barely audible.

Judge Harris looked at her impossible.""

Vanessa's voice was barely audible.

Judge Harris looked at her.

"Are you saying you did not receive money from Mr. Ryan?""

"I received money from him, but he told me it was a.

"Are you saying you did not receive money from Mr. Ryan?""

"I received money from him, but he told me it was a gift.""

Ryan turned sharply.

"Vanessa, stop.""

She ignored him.

"He said he gift.""

Ryan turned sharply.

"Vanessa, stop.""

She ignored him.

"He said he wanted to help me get settled. He said he was taking care of everything.""

Judge Harris placed the financial statement on the wanted to help me get settled. He said he was taking care of everything.""

Judge Harris placed the financial statement on the bench.

"Ms bench.

"Ms. Vanessa, are you aware that approximately eighty-six thousand dollars was transferred into an account registered in your name?""

She stared at the document.

"E. Vanessa, are you aware that approximately eighty-six thousand dollars was transferred into an account registered in your name?""

She stared at the document.

"Eighty-six thousand?""

"That is the amount shown in thisighty-six thousand?""

"That is the amount shown in this record.""

Vanessa looked at Ryan.

"You told me it was record.""

Vanessa looked at Ryan.

"You told me it was forty.""

Ryan's expression hardened.

"You forty.""

Ryan's expression hardened.

"You don't understand the don't understand the figures.""

"Then explain them!""

"Not here.""

figures.""

"Then explain them!""

"Not here.""

"Where, Ryan"Where, Ryan? In another expensive restaurant? Another hotel? Another house you don't own?""

The? In another expensive restaurant? Another hotel? Another house you don't own?""

The last sentence echoed through the courtroom.

last sentence echoed through the courtroom.

I looked down at my hands.

I had spent years trying to understand how Ryan could afford the things he suddenlyI looked down at my hands.

I had spent years trying to understand how Ryan could afford the things he suddenly began buying.

The expensive watch.

The designer clothes.

The weekends away.

The gifts he claimed were business began buying.

The expensive watch.

The designer clothes.

The weekends away.

The gifts he claimed were business incentives.

Now the pieces incentives.

Now the pieces were coming together.

Judge Harris spoke.

"Ms. Vanessa, do you have access were coming together.

Judge Harris spoke.

"Ms. Vanessa, do you have access to the account?""

"Yes.""

"Have you spent any of the money?""

Vanessa hesitated.

to the account?""

"Yes.""

"Have you spent any of the money?""

Vanessa hesitated.

"Some.""

"On what?""

She swallowed.

"Furniture.""Some.""

"On what?""

She swallowed.

"Furniture. A car deposit. Travel. A few personal expenses.""

Ryan leaned toward her.

"You said A car deposit. Travel. A few personal expenses.""

Ryan leaned toward her.

"You said you were going to keep it untouched.""

Vanessa turned.

"You told me it was mine!""

"I said I would take you were going to keep it untouched.""

Vanessa turned.

"You told me it was mine!""

"I said I would take care of you.""

"You gave me money!""

Judge Harris raised his hand.

"Both of you will stop speaking over care of you.""

"You gave me money!""

Judge Harris raised his hand.

"Both of you will stop speaking over each other.""

The room fell quiet.

Park stood each other.""

The room fell quiet.

Park stood.

"Your Honor, we believe the financial records show that the funds transferred to Ms. Vanessa originated.

"Your Honor, we believe the financial records show that the funds transferred to Ms. Vanessa originated from the loan secured against Ms. Elena's property.""

Collins immediately rose.

"Objection. The from the loan secured against Ms. Elena's property.""

Collins immediately rose.

"Objection. The source of the funds has not yet been independently established.""

Park nodded.

"Which source of the funds has not yet been independently established.""

Park nodded.

"Which is why we are requesting the complete bank and lender records.""

Judge Harris considered the is why we are requesting the complete bank and lender records.""

Judge Harris considered the request.

"That request is appropriate. The court will need a complete accounting of the disputed funds.""

Ryan leaned toward request.

"That request is appropriate. The court will need a complete accounting of the disputed funds.""

Ryan leaned toward Collins.

"Can you object to that?""

Collins whispered back.

"I can object to anything. I cannot make the bank records Collins.

"Can you object to that?""

Collins whispered back.

"I can object to anything. I cannot make the bank records disappear.""

Ryan stared at him.

Collins continued.

"And I strongly suggest you stop speaking without disappear.""

Ryan stared at him.

Collins continued.

"And I strongly suggest you stop speaking without consulting me.""

Vanessa looked down at her phone.

Her fingers moved quickly.

Then she raised her head.

" consulting me.""

Vanessa looked down at her phone.

Her fingers moved quickly.

Then she raised her head.

"Your Honor?""

"Yes?""

"I have theYour Honor?""

"Yes?""

"I have the transfer notifications.""

Judge Harris nodded.

"Have you brought them with you?""

"Yes.""

She unlocked her phone.

Park transfer notifications.""

Judge Harris nodded.

"Have you brought them with you?""

"Yes.""

She unlocked her phone.

Park watched carefully.

"Would you be willing to provide them to your own counsel for proper submission watched carefully.

"Would you be willing to provide them to your own counsel for proper submission?""

Vanessa nodded.

"I will.""

Ryan suddenly stood.

"Vanessa, you don't need to do that.""

She looked?""

Vanessa nodded.

"I will.""

Ryan suddenly stood.

"Vanessa, you don't need to do that.""

She looked at him.

"You told me you loved me.""

He stared at her.

"What does that have to do with this?""

"Everything!""

at him.

"You told me you loved me.""

He stared at her.

"What does that have to do with this?""

"Everything!""

Her voice cracked.

"You told me we were starting aHer voice cracked.

"You told me we were starting a new life. You said Elena was the problem. You said the divorce was just a formality.""

She new life. You said Elena was the problem. You said the divorce was just a formality.""

She pointed at the financial statement.

"Was all of this supposed to be our new life?""

Ryan's jaw pointed at the financial statement.

"Was all of this supposed to be our new life?""

Ryan's jaw tightened.

"You wanted the house as much as I did.""

Vanessa went still.

Then she tightened.

"You wanted the house as much as I did.""

Vanessa went still.

Then she slowly shook her head.

"I wanted a home. I didn't ask you to steal one.""

I slowly shook her head.

"I wanted a home. I didn't ask you to steal one.""

I almost laughed.

Not because it was funny.

Because the irony was almost laughed.

Not because it was funny.

Because the irony was unbearable.

The woman who had mocked me for having a cheap lawyer was now trying to distance herself from a man whose unbearable.

The woman who had mocked me for having a cheap lawyer was now trying to distance herself from a man whose financial promises might have been built on my financial promises might have been built on my property.

Judge Harris looked toward Park.

"Counsel, property.

Judge Harris looked toward Park.

"Counsel, do you have anything further regarding the property?""

Park opened the second envelope again.

"One do you have anything further regarding the property?""

Park opened the second envelope again.

"One final item, Your Honor.""

Ryan's head snapped final item, Your Honor.""

Ryan's head snapped up.

"What now?""

Park removed a printed email.

"This up.

"What now?""

Park removed a printed email.

"This communication was sent to the private lender on September twenty-seventh, one day after the date on communication was sent to the private lender on September twenty-seventh, one day after the date on the alleged authorization.""

Judge Harris examined it.

"Who sent it?""

"The email originated from Mr. Ryan the alleged authorization.""

Judge Harris examined it.

"Who sent it?""

"The email originated from Mr. Ryan's business account.""

Collins looked exhausted.

Judge Harris began reading.

His expression changed halfway down's business account.""

Collins looked exhausted.

Judge Harris began reading.

His expression changed halfway down the page.

"Mr. Ryan, did you send this?""

Ryan stared at the paper.

"I don't remember.""

the page.

"Mr. Ryan, did you send this?""

Ryan stared at the paper.

"I don't remember.""

Judge Harris read the relevant section aloud.

"'The owner has already approved the arrangement. WeJudge Harris read the relevant section aloud.

"'The owner has already approved the arrangement. We only need the file processed quickly before she changes her mind.''"

I felt the blood drain from only need the file processed quickly before she changes her mind.''"

I felt the blood drain from my face.

Before she changes her mind.

He had known I didn't approve.

He had known I might my face.

Before she changes her mind.

He had known I didn't approve.

He had known I might object.

And he had wanted the transaction completed before I could discover it.

Ryan finally spoke.

"That was a standard business email.""

Judge Harris object.

And he had wanted the transaction completed before I could discover it.

Ryan finally spoke.

"That was a standard business email.""

Judge Harris looked at him.

"Standard business practice to claim authorization that the looked at him.

"Standard business practice to claim authorization that the registered owner disputes giving?""

Ryan rubbed his forehead.

"Your Honor, I was trying to keep my business afloat.""

Park didn't registered owner disputes giving?""

Ryan rubbed his forehead.

"Your Honor, I was trying to keep my business afloat.""

Park didn't move.

"Was that why you attempted to move.

"Was that why you attempted to transfer the house to Ms. Vanessa?""

Ryan looked at the floor.

No answer.

Judge Harris closed transfer the house to Ms. Vanessa?""

Ryan looked at the floor.

No answer.

Judge Harris closed the folder.

"I have heard enough to issue temporary directions.""

Everyone the folder.

"I have heard enough to issue temporary directions.""

Everyone became still.

"The disputed residence shall not be sold, transferred, refinanced, or otherwise encumbered pending became still.

"The disputed residence shall not be sold, transferred, refinanced, or otherwise encumbered pending further review. Neither party shall take any action intended to alter the current further review. Neither party shall take any action intended to alter the current ownership record.""

Ryan's attorney nodded.

"Understood, Your Honor.""

"The parties shall preserve all communications ownership record.""

Ryan's attorney nodded.

"Understood, Your Honor.""

"The parties shall preserve all communications and financial records relating to the loan, the attempted transfer, and the payments identified today.""

Judge Harris continued.

"The and financial records relating to the loan, the attempted transfer, and the payments identified today.""

Judge Harris continued.

"The court will also require the lender's complete transaction court will also require the lender's complete transaction file and the relevant financial statements before making any final determination concerning the disputed assets.""

Ryan looked devastated.

file and the relevant financial statements before making any final determination concerning the disputed assets.""

Ryan looked devastated.

"Your Honor, what about the divorce?""

"The divorce proceedings will continue"Your Honor, what about the divorce?""

"The divorce proceedings will continue separately from the investigation into the property transaction.""

Ryan shook his head.

"You're treating separately from the investigation into the property transaction.""

Ryan shook his head.

"You're treating me like a criminal.""

Judge Harris looked directly at him.

"I am treating the documents before me seriously. That me like a criminal.""

Judge Harris looked directly at him.

"I am treating the documents before me seriously. That is my responsibility.""

He turned toward Vanessa.

" is my responsibility.""

He turned toward Vanessa.

"Ms. Vanessa, you should seek independent legal advice. Your potential interests may conflict with those of Mr. Ryan.""

VanMs. Vanessa, you should seek independent legal advice. Your potential interests may conflict with those of Mr. Ryan.""

Vanessa nodded.

Her eyes were wet.

Then she did something I hadn't expected.

She turned toward me.

"Elena, canessa nodded.

Her eyes were wet.

Then she did something I hadn't expected.

She turned toward me.

"Elena, can I talk to you?""

Park immediately spoke.

"Not during these proceedings.""

But I I talk to you?""

Park immediately spoke.

"Not during these proceedings.""

But I raised my hand slightly.

"It's all right. Let her speak.""

Park looked at me raised my hand slightly.

"It's all right. Let her speak.""

Park looked at me.

"Are you sure?""

I nodded.

Vanessa approached our table.

She stopped several feet away.

"I know you hate.

"Are you sure?""

I nodded.

Vanessa approached our table.

She stopped several feet away.

"I know you hate me.""

I said nothing.

"I know I deserve some of it.""

Her voice trembled.

"But I didn't know about me.""

I said nothing.

"I know I deserve some of it.""

Her voice trembled.

"But I didn't know about the loan.""

I looked at her.

"You knew he was married.""

She the loan.""

I looked at her.

"You knew he was married.""

She lowered her head.

"Yes.""

"You knew he was promising you my house.""

"I lowered her head.

"Yes.""

"You knew he was promising you my house.""

"I thought he had the right.""

"And you thought I had no right to know?""

Vanessa thought he had the right.""

"And you thought I had no right to know?""

Vanessa began crying.

"I was stupid.""

"No began crying.

"I was stupid.""

"No," I said quietly.

"You were willing to believe whatever made you happy.""

She wiped her face.

"I," I said quietly.

"You were willing to believe whatever made you happy.""

She wiped her face.

"I really did love him.""

I glanced toward Ryan.

He was talking to Collins, apparently more concerned with his legal position really did love him.""

I glanced toward Ryan.

He was talking to Collins, apparently more concerned with his legal position than with the woman crying a few feet away.

"Then perhaps you should ask yourself why he needed my house than with the woman crying a few feet away.

"Then perhaps you should ask yourself why he needed my house to prove he loved you.""

Vanessa looked at him.

Her expression changed.

She returned to prove he loved you.""

Vanessa looked at him.

Her expression changed.

She returned to her seat.

Judge Harris announced a further hearing date.

The bailiff began collecting the documents.

to her seat.

Judge Harris announced a further hearing date.

The bailiff began collecting the documents.

Ryan stood and approached meRyan stood and approached me.

"Elena, we need to talk.""

Park stepped between us.

"Any communication regarding the case should go.

"Elena, we need to talk.""

Park stepped between us.

"Any communication regarding the case should go through counsel.""

Ryan ignored him.

"Elena, please through counsel.""

Ryan ignored him.

"Elena, please. We can settle this privately.""

I looked at him.

"Privately?""

"Yes. I'll make. We can settle this privately.""

I looked at him.

"Privately?""

"Yes. I'll make things right.""

"How?""

"I'll pay you back.""

"With what money?""

He hesitated things right.""

"How?""

"I'll pay you back.""

"With what money?""

He hesitated.

I continued.

"You borrowed against my house. You gave money to Vanessa. You tried to.

I continued.

"You borrowed against my house. You gave money to Vanessa. You tried to transfer the property. What exactly do you have left to offer me?""

His face twisted.

"You're enjoying transfer the property. What exactly do you have left to offer me?""

His face twisted.

"You're enjoying this.""

I looked at the crumpled twenty-dollar bill still lying on my folder.

"No, Ryan.""

I this.""

I looked at the crumpled twenty-dollar bill still lying on my folder.

"No, Ryan.""

I picked it up.

For a moment, I considered putting it in my picked it up.

For a moment, I considered putting it in my purse.

Instead, I placed it gently on his side of the table.

"I'm just no longer paying purse.

Instead, I placed it gently on his side of the table.

"I'm just no longer paying for your mistakes.""

Ryan stared at the banknote.

I walked toward the exit with Park.

Behind me for your mistakes.""

Ryan stared at the banknote.

I walked toward the exit with Park.

Behind me, Vanessa suddenly shouted.

"Ryan! You told me there was another, Vanessa suddenly shouted.

"Ryan! You told me there was another account!""

I stopped.

Park turned slightly.

Ryan went completely still.

Vanessa held up her phone.

account!""

I stopped.

Park turned slightly.

Ryan went completely still.

Vanessa held up her phone.

"You said the money was protected. You said nobody could touch it.""

Ryan whispered something"You said the money was protected. You said nobody could touch it.""

Ryan whispered something.

She shook her head.

"Don't lie to me again.""

Then she looked toward the judge.

"Your Honor, there's something.

She shook her head.

"Don't lie to me again.""

Then she looked toward the judge.

"Your Honor, there's something else you need to know.""

Judge Harris turned back.

"What is it?""

Vanessa took else you need to know.""

Judge Harris turned back.

"What is it?""

Vanessa took a screenshot from her phone and held it toward her attorney.

"It's about the money Ryan a screenshot from her phone and held it toward her attorney.

"It's about the money Ryan transferred after the loan was approved.""

She swallowed.

"He didn't just send transferred after the loan was approved.""

She swallowed.

"He didn't just send it to me.""

Ryan closed his eyes.

Vanessa looked directly it to me.""

Ryan closed his eyes.

Vanessa looked directly at him.

"He sent part of it to someone else.""

And when she finally said the name, Collins at him.

May you like

"He sent part of it to someone else.""

And when she finally said the name, Collins dropped his pen.

Related Stories

Other posts