wink

Chapter 2: The Little Girl With the Red Marker

The judge called for a fifteen-minute recess.

Chairs scraped against the floor. Lawyers gathered their papers. A court officer opened the side door, and the courtroom slowly filled with the low murmur of people discussing the recording.

Sarah remained seated.

She pressed a tissue against her eyes while Melissa rubbed her shoulder.

“You did the right thing,” Melissa whispered.

Sarah nodded.

“I just want Ava to be safe.””

“You've protected her for months.””

Sarah looked toward the defendant's table.

Devon was speaking quietly with Helen. His hands were still cuffed, and he was leaning forward as if every word his attorney said required all his concentration.

Sarah watched him with an expression that could have passed for sadness.

“Look at him,” she whispered.

“He still thinks he can talk his way out of this.””

Melissa followed her gaze.

“He shouldn't be anywhere near Ava.””

“I know.””

Ava sat beside Rachel, drawing on the back of an old envelope.

She had drawn a house.

A yellow sun.

Three people.

One had long brown hair.

One had short black hair.

The third was very small.

Rachel leaned over.

“Is that your family, Ava?””

Ava nodded.

“That's Mommy. That's Daddy. And that's me.””

Rachel smiled.

“That's a beautiful drawing.””

Ava colored the little figure's shirt red.

Then she drew a tiny heart over its chest.

“Why did you draw a heart there?”” Rachel asked.

“Because Daddy says brave people have hearts.””

Rachel's smile softened.

“He sounds like he loves you very much.””

Ava nodded again.

“He does.””

Across the room, Sarah heard the conversation.

Her fingers tightened around the tissue.

“Ava,” she called.

“Come sit with Mommy.””

The little girl looked up.

“I'm drawing.””

“You can draw later, sweetheart.””

Ava didn't move.

Rachel placed a gentle hand on the envelope.

“It's okay. Finish your picture.””

Sarah's expression hardened for a second before she replaced it with a smile.

“Of course. Take your time.””

She turned back to Melissa.

“She gets stubborn when she's tired.””

Melissa nodded.

But Rachel had noticed the way Sarah's voice changed when Ava didn't immediately obey.

She made a note.

Meanwhile, at the defendant's table, Helen Brooks was reading through the documents again.

“Devon, I need you to listen carefully.””

He looked up.

“What?””

“The recording is incomplete. The dispatcher mentioned that the call lasted longer than forty-three seconds. The copy we received was an excerpt.””

“So the rest is still available?””

“It should be.””

“Then get it.””

“I've already requested it. But I want to know something. When you arrived that night, did you see anyone besides Sarah?””

Devon frowned.

“No.””

“Think carefully.””

“I didn't go inside, Helen.””

“I'm not asking whether you went inside. I'm asking whether you saw anyone.””

He rubbed his forehead.

“There was a car parked on the street. A dark SUV. I thought it belonged to a neighbor.””

“Did you recognize it?””

“No.””

“Could you describe it?””

“Not really.””

Helen wrote something down.

“Was the back door open?””

Devon paused.

“What?””

“Sarah's back door. Could you see it from the driveway?””

“I don't know. Why?””

“Because the emergency call says a man was inside the house. But the recording doesn't establish how he entered.””

Devon looked toward Ava.

“Sarah told me she had been home all evening.””

Helen stopped writing.

“When?””

“Three days before. We spoke about Ava's school project. She said she wasn't planning to go anywhere.””

“Did she mention having visitors?””

“No.””

Helen lowered her voice.

“Devon, I need you to understand something. If someone else was inside that house, and if Sarah knew that person was there, we need evidence. Not assumptions.””

“I know.””

“Can you think of anyone who had a reason to be there?””

Devon looked down at his cuffed hands.

Then he remembered something.

A conversation.

A name.

And a message Sarah had deleted before he could read it.

“Maybe,” he said.

Helen waited.

“Her brother.””

“Does Sarah have a brother?””

“Daniel. He used to live with us.””

“Why would he be there?””

Devon shook his head.

“I don't know. But he called me that afternoon.””

Helen's pen stopped.

“What did he say?””

“He asked whether I was going to Sarah's house.””

“And what did you tell him?””

“That I was dropping off Ava's rabbit.””

“Did he say anything else?””

Devon swallowed.

“He told me not to come.””

Helen stared at him.

“Why didn't you tell me this earlier?””

“I didn't think it mattered.””

“Devon, it matters.””

He looked toward the courtroom doors.

“I thought he was just trying to start trouble. He and I never got along.””

Helen closed the folder.

“We'll discuss this after recess.””

At that moment, a court officer approached.

“Mr. Mitchell, the judge is ready.””

Devon stood.

His chains made a small metallic sound.

He looked toward Ava one more time.

She was now drawing something on her palm with the red marker.

A heart.

He smiled faintly.

Ava noticed.

For the first time that morning, her face brightened.

She lifted her hand and waved.

Devon raised his cuffed hands as much as he could.

Then Sarah stepped between them.

“Don't encourage him, Ava.””

The child's smile disappeared.

Devon lowered his hands.

Helen touched his arm.

“Don't react.””

He nodded.

They returned to their seats.

Judge Whitmore entered and took her place.

“Before we continue,” she said, “I would like to hear directly from the child advocate.””

Rachel stood.

“Your Honor, Ava has been cooperative, but she appears uncomfortable whenever the incident is discussed in front of her mother.””

Sarah's head turned sharply.

“That's ridiculous.””

“Ms. Mitchell,” the judge said.

Rachel continued.

“I believe we should allow Ava to speak in a way that does not place additional pressure on her.””

Bennett rose.

“Your Honor, the child has already given a statement to emergency services. We don't want to confuse her by asking repetitive questions.””

Helen stood.

“Then perhaps we should hear the full recording before making any decisions.””

Judge Whitmore nodded.

“That is a reasonable request.””

Sarah leaned toward Bennett.

He whispered something.

She shook her head.

Then, unexpectedly, she stood.

“Your Honor, I don't think my daughter should have to hear that recording again.””

The judge looked at her.

“Why not?””

“Because she was terrified. She's only six.””

“Ms. Mitchell, you introduced the recording.””

“Because it proves what happened.””

“Then it should withstand a complete review.””

Sarah sat down.

Her face had gone pale.

Devon noticed.

Helen noticed too.

And for the first time that morning, she stopped looking at her notes and watched Sarah instead.

The judge turned toward the clerk.

“Please prepare the full emergency call.””

The clerk nodded.

Ava looked up.

“Is that my voice?””

Everyone turned.

Rachel leaned toward her.

“Yes, sweetheart. It's the call you made that night.””

Ava stared at the computer.

“I remember.””

Sarah immediately reached for her.

“Baby, you don't need to worry about that.””

Ava pulled her hand away.

“But I remember what I said.””

Sarah smiled tightly.

“Of course you do. You were scared.””

Ava looked at her mother.

Then at Devon.

Her little fingers closed around the red marker.

“Mommy?””

“What is it?””

“Can Daddy hear me?””

Sarah froze.

Bennett leaned forward.

Judge Whitmore answered before Sarah could.

“Yes, sweetheart. Your daddy is here.””

Ava nodded.

Then she asked a question so quietly that the court reporter almost missed it.

“Can I show him something?””

Sarah's eyes widened.

“No, Ava. Stay here.””

Rachel glanced at the judge.

Judge Whitmore considered the little girl for a moment.

“Let's take things slowly,” she said.

“Ava, what would you like to show your father?””

Ava looked down at her palm.

“The heart.””

Devon felt his throat tighten.

He remembered making that drawing with her months earlier.

They had been sitting on the kitchen floor during a thunderstorm. Ava had been frightened by the thunder, so he had taken a red marker and drawn a heart on his own cheek.

“See?”” he had told her.

“This is my brave heart. It doesn't mean I'm never scared. It means I can be scared and still do the right thing.””

Ava had laughed and drawn one on his other cheek.

Then she had asked him to promise never to forget it.

He hadn't.

He still remembered the smell of her strawberry shampoo.

He still remembered the small pressure of her fingers against his face.

He remembered everything.

“Your Honor,” Helen said carefully, “if Ava wishes to approach her father, perhaps Rachel can accompany her.””

Sarah stood.

“Absolutely not.””

Judge Whitmore looked at her.

“Ms. Mitchell, sit down.””

“But he's dangerous!””

The courtroom went silent.

Ava flinched.

Devon didn't move.

He didn't speak.

He simply looked at his daughter.

May you like

And Ava looked back.

Then, with the red marker clutched in her tiny hand, she stepped around the rail.

Related Stories

Other posts