wink

Chapter 9: What Ava Remembered

Nobody moved.

Ava stood in the doorway, holding Rachel's hand.

Her yellow cardigan was slightly crooked. One ponytail had come loose, and a strand of hair rested against her cheek.

She looked at Devon.

Then at Sarah.

“Did I do something wrong?”” she asked.

Sarah immediately stood.

“No, sweetheart. No. Come here.””

Ava didn't move.

Rachel crouched beside her.

“You're safe, Ava. You can tell us what you remember.””

The little girl looked down.

“Mommy said I had to say it.””

Devon felt his chest tighten.

He wanted to pick her up.

He wanted to tell her that none of this was her fault.

But he waited.

“Sweetheart,” he said softly, “you don't have to say anything you don't want to.””

Ava nodded.

Then she walked toward him.

Rachel followed.

When Ava reached the defendant's table, Devon lowered himself as far as his restraints allowed.

She wrapped both arms around his neck.

He closed his eyes.

“I missed you,” he whispered.

“I missed you too.””

“I'm sorry you got scared.””

Ava pulled back.

“I wasn't scared of you.””

Devon looked at her.

“What were you scared of?””

She glanced toward Sarah.

“Uncle Danny.””

The courtroom remained silent.

Judge Whitmore entered a moment later and took her seat.

She listened carefully as Rachel explained that Ava had spontaneously disclosed additional information.

“I don't want to put words in her mouth,” Rachel said.

“But I believe she should be interviewed in an appropriate setting by a trained child specialist.””

Judge Whitmore nodded.

“I agree.””

Sarah stood.

“Your Honor, I want to explain.””

The judge looked at her.

“You will have an opportunity. But first, I want the child's safety and welfare addressed.””

Sarah lowered her head.

Ava sat beside Rachel.

The judge spoke gently.

“Ava, nobody here is angry with you. You are not in trouble. You can tell the truth, and you don't have to worry about making anyone happy.””

Ava nodded.

Judge Whitmore continued.

“Do you remember talking to your mother before the phone call?””

“Yes.””

“What did she tell you?””

Ava twisted the red marker between her fingers.

“She said if Uncle Danny came downstairs, I should go to my room.””

“Did she tell you anything else?””

“She said I had to call the police if I heard Daddy.””

Devon looked down.

Ava continued.

“She said I should tell them Daddy was inside.””

Sarah made a small choking sound.

Judge Whitmore raised her hand.

“Let her finish.””

Ava looked at the judge.

“Mommy said it was pretend.””

The judge frowned.

“Pretend?””

Ava nodded.

“She said it was like practicing for a fire drill.””

Rachel leaned closer.

“What happened after that, sweetheart?””

Ava looked at the floor.

“Uncle Danny came. Mommy opened the back door. They went downstairs.””

“And what did you do?””

“I went to my room.””

“Did you call the police immediately?””

Ava shook her head.

“No.””

“Why not?””

“Because Mommy said to wait.””

Devon looked at Sarah.

Sarah was crying silently.

Ava continued.

“Then Uncle Danny started shouting. He threw something. Mommy told him to stop.””

“Did you hear anything else?””

“He said the blue folder was missing.””

The detective made a note.

“Did you see the folder?””

Ava nodded.

“It was on the kitchen table.””

“Who had it?””

“Mommy.””

Sarah covered her mouth.

Ava looked at the judge.

“Then Uncle Danny said Daddy was coming, and Mommy told him to hide.””

Devon slowly lifted his head.

“Hide?””

Ava nodded.

“He went behind the kitchen door.””

Rachel asked gently:

“Do you mean a door inside the kitchen?””

Ava shook her head.

“No. The little door.””

The judge glanced toward Detective Harris.

“The concealed compartment?””

The detective nodded.

“That may be the location she described earlier.””

Ava continued.

“Uncle Danny put the phone in there.””

Devon remembered the small black box beneath the floor.

The phone.

The folder.

The documents.

It was beginning to make sense.

“Then what happened?”” Rachel asked.

Ava looked at her father.

“Mommy told me to call.””

The dispatcher had answered.

A frightened six-year-old had told the truth about a man inside the house.

But the adults had tried to make the world believe that man was her father.

“What happened after you called?”” Rachel asked.

Ava hesitated.

“Uncle Danny came upstairs.””

Devon's hands tightened.

“Was he angry?””

Ava nodded.

“He told me to say Daddy was there.””

“Did you?””

“I said Daddy was coming.””

Rachel nodded.

“That's important. What happened next?””

Ava's eyes filled.

“Uncle Danny said I was a bad girl.””

Sarah began crying harder.

The child continued.

“He took my rabbit.””

Devon felt something break inside him.

“Mr. Buttons?””

Ava nodded.

“He said Daddy wasn't getting him back.””

Devon looked at Sarah.

“Where is the rabbit?””

Sarah wiped her face.

“I don't know.””

Ava shook her head.

“It's in the cupboard.””

Everyone turned.

“Which cupboard?”” Rachel asked.

“The one under the stairs.””

The detective immediately wrote it down.

Then Ava added something else.

“Uncle Danny said there was a secret in Mr. Buttons.””

Devon frowned.

“What secret, sweetheart?””

Ava looked toward the judge.

“There's a little card inside.””

Helen stood.

“Your Honor, I request permission for Detective Harris to retrieve the stuffed animal under proper evidence-preservation procedures.””

Judge Whitmore nodded.

“Granted. The child's statement should be documented by the appropriate specialist.””

Sarah slowly rose.

“Your Honor, I need to tell you something.””

The judge looked at her.

“Go ahead.””

Sarah stepped away from her chair.

“I did tell Ava what to say.””

Devon stared at her.

She continued.

“Daniel told me that if the police came, I needed to make sure they believed Devon had entered the house. He said it would buy us time.””

“Time for what?”” Judge Whitmore asked.

“To get the folder.””

“Why was the folder so important?””

Sarah looked at Devon.

“Because page four wasn't just about the trust.””

Helen frowned.

“What else was it about?””

Sarah took a shaky breath.

“Your father had documented every transfer Daniel made from the account. But he also included a separate statement explaining why the money had been moved.””

Devon shook his head.

“What statement?””

Sarah's voice dropped.

“He said the original investment had been made with money from a business sale.””

Devon frowned.

“What business sale?””

“Your father's company.””

Devon stared at her.

“My father sold his company years before he died.””

“Yes.””

“And?””

Sarah swallowed.

“He never told you that he had put part of the proceeds into a separate account.””

Helen leaned forward.

“How much?””

Sarah looked at the judge.

“Almost nine hundred thousand dollars.””

The courtroom erupted in whispers.

Devon couldn't speak.

Nine hundred thousand dollars.

His father had never mentioned that kind of money.

Sarah continued.

“He divided it into several investments. One portion was placed into Ava's trust. Another portion was held in reserve.””

Helen asked:

“Who controlled the reserve account?””

“Your father.””

“And after his death?””

Sarah hesitated.

“Daniel.””

Devon stared at her.

“Why?””

“Because your father gave him temporary access while he was ill.””

Helen's expression hardened.

“Temporary?””

Sarah nodded.

“Daniel was supposed to transfer everything into the independent trust after the funeral.””

“Did he?””

“No.””

“Where did the money go?””

Sarah looked at Devon.

“He used it to pay off his debts.””

Devon slowly sat down.

His father had worked his entire life to build something.

And Daniel had taken it.

But there was still something he didn't understand.

“Why did Dad leave me the letter instead of telling me while he was alive?””

Sarah looked down.

“He tried.””

Devon frowned.

“What?””

“He called you the day before he died.””

Devon went completely still.

“I was working.””

“He asked me to tell you to come to the hospital.””

Devon's face changed.

“I was told he was sleeping.””

Sarah began to cry.

“I know.””

“Who told you that?””

“Daniel.””

Devon looked at the detective.

The detective was already writing.

Helen leaned forward.

“Do you have any evidence of that instruction?””

Sarah nodded.

“Daniel sent me a message.””

She took a breath.

“He told me your father was resting and that I shouldn't disturb you.””

Devon closed his eyes.

He remembered that day.

He had called the hospital twice.

Both times, Sarah had told him his father was asleep.

He had gone to work.

The next morning, his father was dead.

And now he was learning that the man who had stolen from his daughter had also kept him away from his dying father.

Judge Whitmore allowed a short recess.

Devon walked to the window in the corridor.

Rain had started falling outside.

Helen joined him.

“I'm sorry,” she said.

He nodded.

“I should have gone.””

“You were given information by people you trusted.””

“I should have known.””

Helen shook her head.

“Don't take responsibility for someone else's deception.””

Devon stared at the rain.

“Is the money recoverable?””

“We don't know yet.””

“What about Daniel?””

“He's being questioned.””

Devon turned.

“And Sarah?””

Helen paused.

“Her admissions are significant. But the court will have to consider the evidence, not simply the emotions involved.””

Devon nodded.

He understood.

Ava needed stability.

Not another war between her parents.

A few minutes later, Detective Harris approached.

“We found the rabbit.””

Devon turned immediately.

“Mr. Buttons?””

The detective nodded.

“It was in the cupboard beneath the stairs.””

“And the card?””

“We found a small envelope stitched into the lining.””

Helen frowned.

“Stitched?””

“Someone had opened a seam and hidden it inside.””

The detective held up an evidence photograph.

It showed the worn brown rabbit.

One ear was slightly torn.

Devon recognized it instantly.

Ava had carried it everywhere since she was two.

“What was inside?”” he asked.

The detective looked at him.

“A handwritten note and a memory card.””

Helen stepped closer.

“Have you examined it?””

“Not yet. But the note contains a name.””

Devon waited.

The detective turned the photograph around.

Written in blue ink were two words.

*Margaret Ellis.*

Helen's expression changed.

“The trustee.””

Detective Harris nodded.

“There's also a date.””

Devon read it.

It was dated four days before Robert Mitchell died.

Then the detective added:

“We've just spoken with Ms. Ellis. She says she never received the original trust documents.””

Helen frowned.

“Why not?””

The detective looked toward the courtroom.

“Because someone told her the trust had been canceled.””

“Who?””

He glanced at Sarah.

“She says the instruction came from Devon Mitchell.””

Devon felt his stomach drop.

“That isn't true.””

“I know,” Helen replied.

But the detective wasn't finished.

“Ms. Ellis also says she has a signed letter from your father proving that the trust was never canceled.””

Devon looked at the memory card.

“Then where is it?””

Detective Harris took a breath.

“That's the problem. Ms. Ellis says the letter was delivered to her office four years ago.””

“And?””

“She says Daniel collected it the following morning.””

Devon stared at him.

“Why would she give it to Daniel?””

The detective shook his head.

“She didn't. She says he came with a document bearing your signature.””

Helen's face went cold.

“What document?””

Detective Harris looked directly at Devon.

“A power of attorney.””

Devon shook his head.

“I never gave Daniel power of attorney.””

The detective nodded.

“That's what we need to establish.””

He paused.

“Because the document contains a signature that appears to be yours.””

Devon looked toward the courtroom.

Sarah was sitting beside her attorney.

She wasn't looking at him.

She was staring at the floor.

Then, slowly, she lifted her head.

Their eyes met.

And she mouthed something.

I have it.

Devon frowned.

Sarah glanced toward her handbag.

Then back at him.

Helen noticed.

“What?””

Devon pointed.

“Sarah says she has something.””

Helen approached her.

“Ms. Mitchell, what do you have?””

Sarah reached into her handbag and removed a folded piece of paper.

She placed it on the table.

It was a photocopy of a power-of-attorney document.

Devon stared at the signature.

It was his.

Or something designed to look like it.

Helen examined it.

“Where did you get this?””

Sarah's voice trembled.

“Daniel gave it to me.””

“Why?””

“He told me to keep it in case Devon ever tried to challenge the transfers.””

Helen looked up.

“Did you know it was forged?””

Sarah nodded.

Devon closed his eyes.

There it was.

The evidence.

The document that had allowed Daniel to access the trust.

But Sarah wasn't finished.

She looked directly at Devon.

“I didn't tell you because Daniel said he had a second copy.””

“Where?””

Sarah whispered:

“At the bank.””

Devon frowned.

Helen's expression tightened.

“Which bank?””

Sarah gave the name.

First National.

The same bank listed in his father's letter.

The safe-deposit box.

The brass key.

Page four.

Everything was connected.

Then Sarah delivered the final blow.

“Daniel didn't go to the bank alone.””

Devon stared at her.

“Who went with him?””

Sarah looked toward the courtroom entrance.

May you like

Her voice almost disappeared.

“Your father's lawyer.””

Related Stories

Other posts