Chapter 2: The Mirror That Was Never Meant to Open

Eric didn't move immediately.
He remained seated, Lily resting against his chest, while the brass key lay between his fingers.
For several seconds, the only sound in the bathroom was the steady drip of water from the bathtub faucet.
Then he stood.
“Show me,” he said.
Tessa moved in front of the mirror.
“No.””
Eric stopped.
“Excuse me?””
“I said no. You're not going to tear apart the bathroom because Lily found some old key.””
“I'm not tearing anything apart.””
“You're going to frighten her.””
Eric glanced at his daughter.
“She seems frightened already.””
Tessa's expression changed.
She looked at Lily, then at Lorraine.
It was quick, almost imperceptible.
But Eric caught it.
He shifted Lily onto his hip and walked around his wife.
“Move, Tessa.””
She reluctantly stepped aside.
The mirror reflected the three adults and the little girl between them.
Eric leaned closer.
At first, he saw nothing unusual.
The frame was dark walnut, with a slightly worn finish. The lower corners had small decorative carvings. A thin strip of silver-colored metal ran along the inside edge.
He examined the bottom.
No keyhole.
He checked the sides.
Nothing.
“See?”” Tessa said.
“There's nothing there.””
Eric straightened.
“Lily, where exactly did you say it goes?””
She pointed toward the bottom-right corner.
“Under the flower.””
Eric leaned closer again.
There was a small carved flower near the corner of the frame.
He ran his thumb across it.
Something shifted.
A faint metallic click came from inside the wood.
Eric froze.
Tessa's breathing changed.
“Eric,” she said carefully.
“Leave it alone.””
He pressed the carved flower again.
This time, a narrow section of the frame moved inward.
A seam appeared.
It was so thin that he had never noticed it, even after years of cleaning the mirror and standing in front of it every morning.
He ran his finger along the edge.
There.
A concealed keyhole.
Eric stared at it.
“What the hell?””
Lorraine made a small noise behind him.
He turned.
His mother had covered her mouth with one hand.
Tessa looked as though someone had pulled the floor out from beneath her.
Eric held up the key.
“This belongs to this?””
Neither woman answered.
“Mom?””
Lorraine lowered her hand.
“Eric, there are things in this house that are better left undisturbed.””
He looked at her.
“Why?””
“Because not everything needs to be brought back.””
The sentence landed heavily.
Eric felt Lily stiffen against him.
“Brought back from where?””
Lorraine looked at Tessa.
Tessa shook her head almost imperceptibly.
It was a silent exchange.
A warning.
A plea.
And Eric had never seen his mother look at his wife that way before.
He turned back toward the mirror.
“Who installed this?””
Tessa rubbed her forehead.
“Eric, we can talk about this later.””
“Who installed it?””
“The previous owners, I suppose.””
“No. I watched the contractor take down the old mirror when we renovated. This one was custom-made.””
Tessa's eyes flickered.
“You're remembering it wrong.””
“I paid the contractor.””
“Then call him.””
“I might.””
He examined the frame more carefully.
The keyhole was old, much older than the mirror itself. The metal around it had darkened, and the edges were slightly scratched.
Someone had designed the mirror to conceal a lock.
It wasn't decorative.
It was functional.
Eric remembered something.
Four years earlier, when the bathroom renovation was almost finished, the contractor had complained about an unusual backing panel behind the old mirror.
He had said the wall was thicker than expected.
Eric had barely listened.
He had been working late, Tessa had been pregnant, and his mother had been visiting for several weeks after her husband died.
His father.
The memory made Eric pause.
His father had been dead for almost eight years.
And yet, for some reason, the thought of him made the room feel suddenly smaller.
“Dad used to collect old locks,” Eric said.
Lorraine lowered her eyes.
“Yes.””
“Did he know about this?””
She didn't answer.
“Mom?””
“I don't know.””
It was a poor answer.
Eric knew it.
His father had renovated half the house himself before selling it to them. He had been meticulous about unusual fixtures and hidden storage spaces.
If there was a concealed lock in the bathroom, he might have known about it.
But why would he have hidden something behind a mirror?
And why would Lorraine have the key?
Eric glanced at Lily.
“Sweetheart, did you see anything else in Grandma's drawer?””
She nodded.
“A photograph.””
“What photograph?””
“It had a little boy in it.””
Eric felt a strange pull in his stomach.
“Was it Daddy?””
“I don't know. He looked like you.””
Tessa abruptly stepped forward.
“That's enough, Lily.””
Eric turned.
“Don't interrupt her.””
“She doesn't know what she's talking about.””
“Then why are you so desperate to stop her?””
Tessa's eyes flashed.
“Because you're treating every little thing she says like evidence in a criminal investigation!””
Eric stared at her.
“I'm treating her like my daughter.””
For a moment, nobody spoke.
Then Lily whispered, “Grandma said the boy wasn't supposed to know.””
Eric slowly looked toward Lorraine.
“What boy?””
Lorraine's eyes filled with tears.
“Your father made mistakes.””
The words were so unexpected that Eric almost laughed.
“What does Dad have to do with a key in our bathroom?””
“Please,” Lorraine said.
“Not in front of Lily.””
“She's already involved. You made sure of that when you frightened her.””
Lorraine looked at the child.
“I never wanted to frighten you, sweetheart.””
Lily pressed her face into Eric's shoulder.
“You said Daddy wouldn't love me.””
Lorraine closed her eyes.
“I was trying to protect you.””
“From what?””
His mother didn't answer.
Eric looked at Tessa.
“And you?””
Tessa folded her arms.
“I don't know what you want me to say.””
“The truth would be a good start.””
She looked toward the keyhole again.
Her eyes lingered there.
Then she whispered, “Some things can't be undone.””
Eric felt the hair rise along his arms.
“What does that mean?””
“Nothing.””
“No. You don't get to say something like that and pretend it means nothing.””
Tessa walked toward him.
“Eric, listen to me. Your father had a complicated past. There were things your mother never told you. That's all.””
“Then tell me.””
“I can't.””
“Why?””
“Because it's not my story to tell.””
Eric looked at Lorraine.
His mother was crying now, silently, without wiping her cheeks.
That frightened him more than Tessa's anger.
He had seen Lorraine cry at funerals, hospital beds, and the day they buried his father.
But this was different.
She looked like someone waiting for a door to open.
Someone who knew what was on the other side.
Eric looked down at the key.
The red thread tied to it was faded, but there was a tiny white tag attached.
He turned it over.
Two letters had been written in faded blue ink.
E.M.
His initials.
Eric Mitchell.
He stared at them.
“Why would my initials be on a key that belongs to this mirror?””
Tessa swallowed.
Lorraine made a faint sound.
Eric turned the key over again.
Beneath his initials was a date.
A date from twenty-nine years earlier.
The year Eric was born.
He looked at his mother.
“Mom, what happened when I was born?””
Lorraine began shaking her head.
“Please don't.””
“Why?””
“Your father said you must never—”
She stopped.
Eric stepped closer.
“Must never what?””
Lorraine pressed both hands against her mouth.
Tessa whispered, “Lorraine, stop.””
But Eric was already looking at the keyhole.
His father had hidden something behind the bathroom mirror.
The key had been marked with his initials and the year he was born.
And both women had spent the afternoon trying to keep their seven-year-old daughter from revealing it.
He had no intention of walking away.
“I'm opening it,” Eric said.
Tessa grabbed the edge of the sink.
“Eric, you don't understand.””
“Then explain it.””
“I can't.””
“Why not?””
Her eyes met his.
For the first time, he saw something in them that he couldn't mistake for anger or embarrassment.
She was terrified.
May you like
And then she said something that made him question everything he thought he knew about his marriage.
“Because the last person who opened that mirror disappeared.””