wink

Chapter 7: The Brother Who Came Back

The doorbell rang again.

Eric stood motionless in the upstairs hallway, the photograph of the two boys trembling in his hand.

Three rings.

Then silence.

Behind the bathroom mirror, something knocked once more.

Lorraine grabbed the banister.

“Don't open that door!””

Detective Harris immediately reached for his radio.

“Units responding to the Mitchell residence, we have a possible suspect at the front entrance. Hold your positions.””

Eric looked at him.

“You said my brother checked into a hotel two streets away. Why would he be here?””

Harris didn't answer immediately.

“Because he may have been watching this house.””

Tessa pulled Lily toward her.

“Eric, we need to leave.””

He turned.

“Why?””

“Because Daniel knows the mirror has been opened.””

“How?””

Tessa looked at the photograph.

“Because he knows what's inside.””

Eric felt anger rising again.

“You've known about him all these years. You've known about the mirror. You've known about my father. What else have you been keeping from me?””

Tessa opened her mouth.

A heavy knock sounded downstairs.

“Sheriff's Department!”” a man shouted.

“Open the door!””

Harris moved toward the staircase.

“Stay here.””

Eric followed him.

“I am not letting another stranger walk into my house without knowing what's happening.””

“Mr. Mitchell, I need you to stay with your daughter.””

“Then explain what you're afraid of.””

Harris stopped halfway down the stairs.

“Your brother was involved in the original investigation. We believe he has been trying to recover evidence hidden by your father.””

“What evidence?””

“The identities of several people who disappeared from the county over twenty years ago.””

Eric frowned.

“What does that have to do with me?””

Harris looked at him.

“Your father believed you were the only person who could identify the man responsible.””

Eric stared.

“I was ten.””

“I know.””

Another knock sounded.

Then a voice came through the front door.

“Eddie?””

Eric stopped breathing.

It was the same voice he had heard behind the mirror.

“Eddie, I know you're in there.””

Lorraine began sobbing upstairs.

Tessa closed her eyes.

Eric moved toward the door.

Harris stepped in front of him.

“Don't.””

“That's my brother.””

“Or someone pretending to be.””

The voice came again.

“Eddie, please. I don't have much time.””

Eric looked through the peephole.

A man stood on the porch.

He was in his early thirties, wearing a dark jacket and holding a small paper bag.

His hair was black.

His face was pale.

But it was his eyes that made Eric's stomach tighten.

They were the same eyes as the boy in the photograph.

The man lifted his head.

He looked directly into the peephole.

Then he smiled sadly.

“Hello, little brother.””

Eric unlocked the door.

Harris caught his arm.

“Wait.””

But Eric was already pulling the door open.

The man stood there without moving.

For several seconds, neither brother spoke.

Then the stranger looked past Eric.

“Is Mom upstairs?””

Eric's voice came out rough.

“Who are you?””

The man glanced at him.

“Daniel.””

“Prove it.””

Daniel reached into his jacket.

Harris immediately raised his weapon.

“Hands where I can see them!””

Daniel froze.

“Easy. I'm not armed.””

“Keep your hands visible.””

Daniel slowly withdrew a small object.

A silver toy soldier.

Eric stared.

He recognized it.

When he was a child, he had owned a collection of miniature soldiers. One had been broken at the waist, and his father had repaired it with a tiny brass pin.

He had lost it during a family vacation.

Or so he had always believed.

Daniel held it out.

“Dad gave me this the night they took me away.””

Eric didn't take it.

“Who took you?””

Daniel's smile disappeared.

He looked toward the staircase.

“Grandma.””

Behind them, Lorraine made a sound like someone had struck her.

Daniel stepped inside.

Harris blocked his path.

“You're coming with me.””

Daniel looked at him.

“Not until he hears what happened.””

“You've been missing for twenty-two years.””

“I know.””

“You're a person of interest in an open investigation.””

Daniel gave a tired laugh.

“Then you should probably investigate the people who kept me hidden.””

Eric moved between them.

“Tell me what happened.””

Daniel looked at his brother.

Then he glanced toward Lily.

“Is that your daughter?””

“Yes.””

Daniel's face softened.

“What's her name?””

“Lily.””

Daniel crouched slightly.

“Hello, Lily.””

The little girl hid behind Tessa.

Daniel didn't approach her.

“It's okay. I won't come closer.””

Eric studied him.

“You knew about the mirror?””

Daniel nodded.

“Dad built it to hide something.””

“What?””

“Records. Photographs. Names.””

“Why?””

“Because he discovered Grandma was running something much bigger than he understood.””

Lorraine appeared at the top of the stairs.

“That's a lie.””

Daniel looked up.

“Hello, Mother.””

Lorraine gripped the banister.

“You have no right to come here.””

Daniel laughed bitterly.

“No right? You locked me in a room for three days when I was ten. You told everyone I had died. You made Dad choose between protecting me and protecting Eddie.””

Eric turned toward his mother.

“Is that true?””

Lorraine shook her head.

“Daniel was unstable. He was dangerous.””

Daniel pulled up his sleeve.

A long pale scar ran along his forearm.

“You remember this?””

Lorraine said nothing.

“You told the doctor I fell through a glass door. I was trying to get away from you.””

Eric looked at the scar.

Then at the man.

His brother.

A person he had never known existed.

“Why did Dad let you disappear?””

Daniel's expression changed.

“He didn't.””

“What?””

“Dad helped me escape. He told me to wait until he could come back for me.””

Eric felt his throat tighten.

“Did he?””

Daniel lowered his eyes.

“No.””

Silence filled the hallway.

Daniel continued.

“Three days later, someone came to the place where Dad had hidden me. They told me he was dead. They showed me a photograph of his hospital bed.””

Eric looked at Harris.

“The body wasn't his.””

The detective nodded slowly.

“That's what we suspect.””

Daniel looked at his brother.

“But I know something else. Dad didn't die eight years ago.””

Eric felt his heart pounding.

“Where is he?””

Daniel glanced toward the bathroom.

“He's closer than you think.””

Lorraine suddenly shouted.

“STOP!””

Daniel turned.

“You're still afraid of him?””

“I'm afraid of what he'll do to this family!””

Daniel's expression hardened.

“He already did.””

He reached into the paper bag and removed a small envelope.

He handed it to Eric.

“Dad told me to give you this if the mirror ever opened.””

Eric looked at the handwriting.

His father's.

The envelope was sealed with red wax.

He broke it open.

Inside was a photograph.

It showed the bathroom mirror from the other side.

Behind the glass stood an older man wearing a dark cardigan.

His hair was almost completely white.

His face was thinner.

But Eric recognized him immediately.

His father.

On the back of the photograph was a message.

Eddie, I am not behind the mirror.

Eric looked up.

Daniel was watching him.

“What does that mean?””

Daniel's eyes filled.

“It means Dad was never trapped in that room.””

Eric looked at the photograph again.

The man standing behind the glass was holding a piece of paper against it.

Three words were written in thick black ink.

*ASK YOUR WIFE.*

Eric slowly turned toward Tessa.

She was crying.

May you like

And for the first time, she didn't look surprised.

She looked caught.

Related Stories

Other posts