wink

Chapter 2: The Heart on His Cheek

“Can I go to Daddy?””

The question was so quiet that Judge Hollis almost didn't hear it.

Sarah's hand tightened around Ava's shoulder.

“No, honey. You stay right here.””

Ava looked up at her mother.

“But I want to.””

“Sweetheart, remember what we talked about?””

Ava lowered her eyes.

Judge Hollis removed his glasses.

“Mrs. Mitchell, release your daughter's shoulder.””

Sarah hesitated.

“Your Honor, I don't think that's appropriate. He's been frightening her for months.””

“Then she should have no difficulty explaining her feelings without physical prompting.””

Sarah withdrew her hand.

Ava took one small step toward the courtroom rail.

The bailiff moved to intercept her, but Judge Hollis raised a hand.

“Let her approach, under supervision.””

Devon couldn't move.

The handcuffs were secured behind his back, and the chain between them rattled when he shifted his weight.

He wanted to reach for his daughter.

He wanted to pull her into his arms and tell her that everything was going to be okay.

But he was afraid that even the smallest movement might scare her.

So he did the only thing he could.

He slowly lowered himself to one knee.

The courtroom became silent.

“Hi, princess,” he whispered.

Ava stopped a few feet away.

“Hi, Daddy.””

Devon's lips trembled.

“Look how tall you've gotten.””

“I'm seven now.””

“I know. I missed your birthday.””

Ava nodded.

“You weren't there.””

“No, sweetheart. I wasn't.””

“Mommy said you didn't want to come.””

Devon closed his eyes for a moment.

When he opened them, he looked directly at his daughter.

“I wanted to be there more than anything.””

Sarah made an impatient sound.

“Ava, don't let him confuse you.””

Judge Hollis turned toward her.

“Mrs. Mitchell, remain seated.””

Ava reached into her cardigan pocket.

She pulled out a short red crayon.

Devon watched her carefully.

“What are you drawing, sweetheart?””

Ava didn't answer.

She stepped closer, raised her small hand, and touched the crayon to his right cheek.

A thin red line appeared.

Then another.

She drew slowly, concentrating as she had at the kitchen table months earlier.

Devon stayed perfectly still.

When she finished, she stepped back.

It was a heart.

A small, slightly crooked red heart.

Devon's face crumpled.

He recognized the shape immediately.

It matched the half-heart on the torn drawing.

He brought his cuffed hands forward as far as the restraints allowed, pressing them against his chest.

A sob escaped him.

“Oh, Ava.””

The little girl looked at his cheek.

“Now you have your half.””

Devon shook his head, tears falling freely.

“You remembered.””

“I remember everything.””

Sarah stood abruptly.

“That's enough!””

Judge Hollis struck the desk with his gavel.

“Sit down, Mrs. Mitchell!””

“But she's being manipulated!””

“No. At this moment, you are the only person interrupting her.””

Sarah slowly sat, her face flushed.

Ava glanced at her father again.

“Daddy?””

“Yes, baby?””

“Do you remember when we made the picture?””

Devon nodded.

“The picture with the blue house?””

“And the doorway.””

His expression changed.

“Yes.””

Ava held up the torn fragment.

“Mommy said this part was bad.””

Devon stared at the paper.

“What part, sweetheart?””

“The part where the scary man was.””

Sarah's chair scraped against the floor.

“Your Honor, I object to this entire interaction. The child is confused.””

Judge Hollis looked at Ava.

“Can you explain what you mean?””

Ava nodded.

She pointed at the fragment.

“This is the picture Mommy took from my room.””

Sarah's expression hardened.

“That's enough, Ava.””

Ava continued.

“I drew Daddy by the door because he was helping me.””

Devon blinked.

“Helping you with what?””

Ava looked down at her shoes.

“With the noise.””

The words landed heavily in the courtroom.

Judge Hollis leaned forward.

“What noise, Ava?””

“The banging.””

Sarah shook her head.

“She has nightmares. That's all.””

Ava looked at her mother.

“No, Mommy. It wasn't a nightmare.””

The courtroom fell silent again.

Devon felt his heart pounding.

He remembered the night Ava had called him from her bedroom, frightened by something happening in the hallway.

He remembered sitting outside her door until she fell asleep.

But he also remembered something else.

Sarah had insisted that the incident never happened.

Ava turned the drawing around.

“Daddy said I should draw what I saw, not what somebody told me to draw.””

Sarah's face went pale.

Judge Hollis glanced at the torn edge.

“Who told you to draw this?””

Ava answered without hesitation.

“Daddy.””

“And who told you to tear it?””

Ava looked at her mother.

“Mommy.””

Sarah stood again.

“Your Honor, this is becoming ridiculous. The child has been exposed to inappropriate conversations.””

Judge Hollis's voice dropped.

“Mrs. Mitchell, sit down immediately.””

Sarah obeyed, but her fingers were trembling.

Ava slipped the red crayon back into her pocket.

Then she looked at the judge.

“I brought the other part.””

Devon stopped breathing.

Sarah's head snapped toward her daughter.

“What?””

Ava reached inside her cardigan again.

This time, she pulled out a folded piece of paper.

It was creased into four small squares, as though someone had tried to make it disappear inside a child's pocket.

Ava held it against her chest.

“Mommy said I wasn't allowed to show anybody.””

Judge Hollis leaned forward.

“May I see it, Ava?””

Ava looked at Devon.

He nodded gently.

“It's okay, sweetheart.””

May you like

She took one step toward the bench.

And Sarah suddenly lunged from her chair.

Related Stories

Other posts