Chapter 7: The Brother in the Photograph

Devon had spent eleven years visiting his brother's grave.
Eleven birthdays.
Eleven Christmases.
Eleven anniversaries of the accident.
He had stood beside a marble headstone in a cemetery outside Atlanta, leaving flowers and apologizing for things he could never take back.
Now Sarah was telling him that the man buried beneath that stone wasn't Michael.
“Take that back,” Devon whispered.
Sarah shook her head.
“I can't.””
“Michael died in front of me.””
“You saw a body.””
“I identified him!””
“You identified what we told you to identify.””
Devon grabbed the edge of the courtroom rail.
“What did you do?””
Judge Hollis immediately intervened.
“Mr. Mitchell, step away from the rail.””
Devon didn't move.
Detective Reed approached him.
“Sir, I need you to remain calm.””
Devon looked at the detective.
“My brother is dead.””
Sarah lowered her eyes.
“I'm sorry.””
“Don't you dare apologize to me. Tell me what happened.””
For the first time that morning, Sarah seemed unable to construct a convincing answer.
Judge Hollis instructed the clerk to suspend the custody discussion temporarily.
“Detective Reed, I suggest you begin an independent investigation into the identity of the individual buried under Michael Mitchell's name.””
“Yes, Your Honor.””
Sarah suddenly spoke.
“You won't find him.””
The detective turned.
“Why?””
“Because Michael changed his name.””
Devon let out a short, disbelieving laugh.
“My brother didn't change his name.””
Sarah looked at him.
“You didn't know him as well as you thought.””
Devon felt anger rising through his chest.
“Michael was my best friend. We grew up in the same bedroom. He taught me how to drive.
He stood beside me at my wedding. Don't tell me what I knew about my own brother.””
Sarah's eyes filled.
“Then why didn't he come to your wedding reception?””
Devon stopped.
It was a strange question.
He remembered Michael arriving at the church.
He remembered photographs of the two of them.
But he also remembered that his brother had disappeared before the reception.
Sarah had said he was feeling sick.
“Because he had a migraine,” Devon replied.
Sarah shook her head.
“He was meeting someone.””
“Who?””
“Margaret.””
Devon stared at her.
“My mother-in-law?””
Sarah nodded.
“They had been talking for months.””
Detective Reed opened his notebook.
“About what?””
Sarah looked toward the judge.
“About a child.””
Devon felt his heart stumble.
Ava.
He looked toward the door where his daughter had disappeared.
“Was Michael Ava's biological father?””
Sarah began crying.
“No.””
“Then whose child was she?””
Sarah pressed her palms against her face.
“I don't know anymore.””
Detective Reed stepped closer.
“Mrs. Mitchell, you need to stop speaking in fragments. Give us the facts.””
Sarah took a trembling breath.
“Michael discovered that Margaret had been keeping two sets of medical records. One belonged to Ava. The other belonged to another baby.””
Devon frowned.
“Another baby?””
“Margaret worked at a private maternity clinic years ago. She had access to patient records. She discovered that a child had been registered under the wrong name.””
“Whose child?””
Sarah hesitated.
“Mine.””
Devon felt the room tilt.
“What are you talking about?””
Sarah continued.
“When Ava was born, Margaret told me something had gone wrong at the hospital. She said another family had lost their baby, and that there had been a mix-up.””
Devon shook his head.
“No.””
“I was young. I was terrified. Margaret told me the hospital had corrected everything.””
“You're telling me Ava was switched at birth?””
Sarah nodded.
Devon stared at her.
“Did you know before today?””
Sarah began sobbing harder.
“I found out the truth after Michael's accident.””
Judge Hollis leaned forward.
“Mrs. Mitchell, did you report this alleged medical error?””
“No.””
“Why?””
“Because Margaret told me the other child had died.””
Devon looked at the photograph of Margaret again.
“Then why was she still alive?””
Sarah swallowed.
“Because she knew the other family was looking for their daughter.””
The courtroom went silent.
Detective Reed asked, “And Michael?””
Sarah looked down.
“He discovered the truth. He wanted to tell Devon.””
“Why didn't he?””
“Because he disappeared before he could.””
Devon shook his head.
“No. He died.””
Sarah stared at him.
“Devon, the night of the accident, I received a phone call from Margaret. She said Michael was coming to Atlanta to meet you. Then she called again and said there had been an accident.””
“And?””
“And the man in the car wasn't Michael.””
Detective Reed wrote something down.
“Who identified the body?””
“Margaret.””
Devon closed his eyes.
His mother-in-law had supposedly identified his brother.
The same woman who had apparently faked her own death.
The same woman Ava had drawn standing in the doorway.
The same woman who had hidden a red box.
“Why did you lie to me?”” Devon asked.
Sarah looked at him through her tears.
“Because Margaret said if you discovered the truth, you would lose Ava.””
“She was my daughter.””
“She said you would take her away.””
Devon laughed bitterly.
“You were the one who took her away!””
Sarah flinched.
Judge Hollis raised his hand.
“Mrs. Mitchell, do you have any documentation supporting these claims?””
Sarah nodded.
“The red box.””
Detective Reed closed his notebook.
“We will need to locate it.””
“It's in Unit 214,” Sarah whispered.
“Then why did you say you didn't know where it was?””
“Because Margaret took the key.””
The detective paused.
“Who gave it to her?””
Sarah looked toward the photograph.
“Someone who entered the storage facility three days ago.””
“Who?””
Sarah's lips trembled.
“My daughter.””
Devon stared at her.
“Ava?””
Sarah nodded.
“She found the spare key in my bedroom. She must have taken it when I wasn't looking.””
Devon suddenly remembered the purple number written on the receipt.
Ava had known about Unit 214.
She had carried the receipt into court.
And she had kept the second half of the drawing hidden in her cardigan.
Judge Hollis looked toward the court officer.
“Bring Ava back, please. I want to ask her one question, with appropriate safeguards.””
A few minutes later, Ava returned.
She walked directly to Devon.
He gently took her hand.
Judge Hollis spoke softly.
“Ava, did you visit a storage facility recently?””
She nodded.
“Did you open a unit there?””
Ava looked at her father.
Then she whispered:
“Yes.””
“Who went with you?””
Ava reached into her cardigan.
She removed a small photograph.
It showed a woman standing beside a little girl.
The woman was Margaret.
The little girl was Ava.
And on the back, in familiar handwriting, were six words:
*I found the other half, Grandma.*
Devon stared at the photograph.
“Where did you get this?””
Ava looked up.
“Grandma gave it to me.””
“When?””
“Three days ago.””
Detective Reed immediately took the photograph.
“Where is she now, Ava?””
Ava pointed toward the courtroom entrance.
“She said she'd wait outside until Daddy was ready to hear the truth.””
Everyone turned toward the doors.
But the hallway was empty.
Margaret was gone.
May you like
And on the photograph, beneath the message, was an address Devon recognized.
It belonged to the cemetery where Michael was buried.