Chapter 5: The Red Box

Judge Hollis didn't immediately respond.
He placed the photograph on top of the death certificate.
“Mrs. Mitchell, explain that statement.””
Sarah stared at the floor.
“I was upset. I didn't mean it that way.””
“Then tell me what you meant.””
Sarah shook her head.
“I can't.””
Devon leaned forward.
“Sarah, what happened that night?””
She looked at him for the first time.
“You should have stayed out of the basement.””
The words struck him harder than a slap.
Devon remembered the locked door.
The smoke.
Margaret's trembling hands.
And the words about the red box.
Judge Hollis motioned for the court officer to remain near Sarah.
“Mrs. Mitchell, I am giving you one opportunity to clarify your statement.””
Sarah wiped her cheeks.
“My mother had been sick for years. She wasn't thinking clearly. She was confused, paranoid, and constantly accusing people of stealing from her.””
“Who?””
“Me. My husband. Everyone.””
Devon frowned.
“That isn't true.””
“You never knew her the way I did!””
“I knew her well enough to know she loved Ava.””
Sarah let out a bitter laugh.
“She loved keeping secrets more than she loved anyone.””
Ava shifted in her chair.
“Mommy?””
Sarah looked at her.
“What?””
“Grandma wasn't sick.””
Sarah's expression hardened.
“Sweetheart, adults are talking.””
“But Grandma wasn't sick when I saw her.””
Judge Hollis gently interrupted.
“Ava, you don't have to answer any more questions right now.””
The little girl nodded.
Then she reached for the folded drawing on the clerk's table.
“Can I tell you about the box?””
The judge considered her request.
“Only if you want to, Ava.””
She nodded.
“Grandma had a red box in her bedroom. It was under the bed. She told me it was important.””
Devon remembered Margaret's basement whisper.
Find the red box.
“What was inside it?”” he asked.
Ava shook her head.
“I didn't open it. Grandma said only Daddy could.””
Sarah's chair scraped backward.
“That's enough!””
Judge Hollis raised his hand.
“Mrs. Mitchell, control yourself.””
Sarah turned toward the judge.
“Your Honor, she's repeating things she heard from her grandmother. Margaret was unstable. She was constantly filling Ava's head with stories.””
Ava looked confused.
“But Grandma said you knew.””
Sarah went completely still.
Judge Hollis noticed.
“Knew what?””
Ava's small voice trembled.
“That Daddy didn't start the fire.””
Devon felt his stomach tighten.
He had never been accused of starting the fire until Sarah filed her complaint.
He looked toward the judge.
“Your Honor, Sarah told the police I deliberately locked Margaret in the basement.””
Sarah immediately turned.
“Because you did!””
“No,” Devon said.
“The lock was on the outside. I forced it open.””
“You were the only one with a key!””
“I didn't even know that door was locked!””
Judge Hollis raised his voice.
“Both of you will stop speaking over one another.””
He turned toward the clerk.
“Has the court received any additional information about the photograph?””
The clerk shook his head.
“Not yet, Your Honor.””
Ava slowly climbed down from her chair.
The court officer approached her.
“Do you need something, sweetheart?””
“I need to tell Daddy something.””
Devon lowered himself slightly.
“I'm listening.””
Ava looked at Sarah first.
Then she whispered:
“Grandma said Mommy took the box because of the papers.””
Sarah's face drained of color.
“What papers?”” Judge Hollis asked.
Ava pointed at the picture.
“The papers that had the names.””
Devon looked at Sarah.
“What names?””
Sarah didn't answer.
Ava continued.
“Grandma said Mommy was afraid Daddy would find out about the money.””
The courtroom went silent.
Judge Hollis sat back.
“Mrs. Mitchell, what money is the child referring to?””
Sarah shook her head.
“Nothing. She doesn't understand.””
Devon slowly stood.
“What money, Sarah?””
She turned toward him.
“Don't pretend you were innocent.””
“I'm asking you a question.””
“You signed everything!””
“I signed what?””
Sarah's voice cracked.
“The insurance documents!””
Devon stared at her.
“What insurance documents?””
For a moment, Sarah looked as though she had said too much.
Then she closed her eyes.
Judge Hollis leaned toward the clerk.
“Please record that statement.””
Devon's thoughts raced.
He had purchased life insurance years earlier, naming Sarah as the beneficiary. It was a standard policy through his employer.
But he had never signed anything relating to Margaret.
“Sarah,” he said slowly, “what did you do?””
She looked at him with wet eyes.
“You think you're the victim in all this?””
“I'm standing here in handcuffs because you told people I hurt our daughter.””
“I was protecting her!””
“From what?””
Sarah's voice rose.
“From finding out what kind of family she came from!””
Ava began crying again.
Devon immediately lowered his voice.
“Please don't scare her.””
Sarah pointed at him.
“You don't get to tell me how to raise my child.””
Judge Hollis struck his gavel.
“Mrs. Mitchell, I have had enough.””
He turned to the bailiff.
“Remove the handcuffs from Mr. Mitchell for the remainder of this hearing, provided he remains under supervision. There is no justification for maintaining restraints solely on the basis of untested allegations.””
The bailiff approached Devon.
The metal clicked open.
Devon rubbed his wrists.
For the first time that morning, he could move his hands freely.
He looked at Ava.
She ran toward him.
He caught her gently and held her against his chest.
“I'm sorry, baby,” he whispered.
Ava buried her face in his shirt.
“I knew you weren't bad.””
Devon closed his eyes.
Then she pulled away slightly.
“Daddy?””
“Yes?””
“Grandma said the red box wasn't the only thing Mommy hid.””
He looked down at her.
“What else did she hide?””
Ava reached into her cardigan and produced a tiny folded receipt.
It had been tucked behind the lining.
Devon opened it.
It was from a storage facility in Atlanta.
The rental date was seven months earlier.
The account holder was Sarah Mitchell.
And in the section marked Unit Number, someone had written a number in purple crayon.
*214.*
Devon looked up.
Sarah was staring at the receipt.
For the first time since the hearing began, she looked genuinely defeated.
Judge Hollis extended his hand.
“Mr. Mitchell, may I see that?””
Devon passed it to him.
The judge examined the receipt.
“Mr. Lewis, contact the appropriate authorities and preserve this document.””
Sarah began shaking her head.
“No. You can't.””
Judge Hollis looked at her.
“Why not?””
“Because you don't know what's in there.””
Devon stared at his wife.
“Then tell us.””
Sarah covered her face.
A long silence followed.
May you like
Then she whispered:
“Because if you open that storage unit, you'll find out that your daughter wasn't the only child I lied about.””